Director of Liquidations v. Central Trust Co.
Director of Liquidations v. Central Trust Co.
Opinion of the Court
This is a suit in equity against Nathan H. Gordon Corporation and Sarah Scovell under G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 167, § 24, as amended by St. 1933, c. 41, § 4, to enforce their individual liability as stockholders in the insolvent Central Trust Company on May 10, 1932, when the commissioner of banks took possession of said Central Trust Company. The liability is created by G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 172, § 24. See now St. 1934, c. 349, § 14; St. 1937, c. 248. The liability is fastened upon “stockholders” without further description. Friede v. Mackey, 298 Mass. 193, 194.
The facts appear in the report of a master, which was confirmed. On the crucial date, May 10, 1932, no shares of the Central Trust Company stood in the name of the defendant
The Nathan H. Gordon Corporation would have been liable unless on May 10, 1932, it had done all that it could do to divest itself of the indicia of title to the stock. Commissioner of Banks v. Waltham Trust Co. 293 Mass. 62, 65. Director of Liquidations v. Wood, 306 Mass. 1, 5. But in this case the stock was actually transferred before that date on the books of the trust company to Sarah Scovell. There is no finding of a conspiracy to escape liability. Bowden v. Johnson, 107 U. S. 251, 261. Matteson v. Dent, 176 U. S. 521, 531. Cox v. Montague, 78 Fed. 845. Neither is there a finding that Nathan H. Gordon Corporation knew that Sarah Scovell was only a straw for Nathan H. Gordon, if such knowledge would be material. We think that Nathan H. Gordon Corporation is not liable. Neither, in our opinion, is Sarah Scovell, for she never was consciously a stockholder. Keyser v. Hitz, 133 U. S. 138, 149. Williams v. Vreeland, 250 U. S. 295.
It is not doubted that Nathan H. Gordon, who died on June 3, 1938, would have been liable as the real owner on
Interlocutory decree affirmed.
Final decree affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Director of Liquidations v. Central Trust Company & others
- Status
- Published