Wilson v. MacDonald
Wilson v. MacDonald
Opinion of the Court
In this action of tort for conscious suffering and death of Edward Wilson, the plaintiff’s intestate (Wilson), the jury returned verdicts for the plaintiff. The case was heard originally by an auditor, findings of fact not to be final, who found that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover. The case is before us on the defendant’s exceptions to the denial of his motions for directed verdict, for verdict under leave reserved, and for a new trial, and to the admission in evidence of testimony given by him at a previous trial.
We consider the evidence most favorable to the plaintiff. Morton v. Dobson, 307 Mass. 394, 396. Donnelly v. Larkin, 327 Mass. 287, 289. On July 29, 1959, at about 1 a.m., Wilson was in his automobile being towed in a westerly direction on Boston Road in Wilbraham. Having been signaled by Wilson, the driver of the towing car (Wilson’s son) drove to the side of the road and stopped. A car approached from the west at high speed, struck the left front door of Wilson’s car and continued in an easterly direction without stopping. The driver of the hit and run vehicle wore a short sleeved white shirt, and his hair was matted “like it was wet.” Subsequent to the accident the defendant approached the scene driving a two toned light colored
There was no error. There was sufficient evidence for the case to go to the jury. See Sutherland v. Feinberg, 261 Mass. 394. The jury could reasonably infer that it was more likely than not that the defendant was responsible for Wilson’s injuries. Compare Atlas v. Silsbury-Gamble Motors Co. 278 Mass. 279. The motion for a new trial was properly denied. See Bartley v. Phillips, 317 Mass. 35, 42. Nor did the judge err in the admission in evidence of a portion of a transcript of the evidence from a previous trial. General Laws c. 233, § 80, authorizes the admission of such evidence, and it is to be presumed that the judge made all requisite preliminary findings. See Taylor v. Harrington, 243 Mass. 210, 213; Chadwick & Carr Co. v. Smith, 293 Mass. 293, 295.
Exceptions overruled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Clara W. Wilson, administratrix v. John H. MacDonald
- Status
- Published