Under Armour, Inc. v. Battle Fashions, Inc.
Cases that cite this one
11 later published cases cite this decision. The 10 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Big Birds, LLC v. Vanity Online (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
- Temescal Wellness of Maryland, LLC v. Faces Human Capital, LLC (District Court, D. Maryland 2021)
- Rogers v. Senk (United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida 2020)
- Rogers v. Senk (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
- White v. NewRez, LLC (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
- Choice Hotels International , Inc. v. Jai Sai Baba, LLC (District Court, D. Maryland 2023)
- Choice Hotels International, Inc. v. Jai Sai Baba, LLC (District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania 2023)
- Blackstone International, Ltd. v. Zhejiang Mikia Lighting Co., Ltd. (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
- O'Reilly v. Tsottles (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
- Coastal Laboratories, Inc. v. Jolly (District Court, D. Maryland 2020)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff Under Armour, Inc. ("Plaintiff" or "UA") brings this declaratory judgment action against Defendants Battle Fashions, Inc.
BACKGROUND
When reviewing a motion to dismiss, this Court accepts as true the facts alleged in the plaintiff's complaint. See Aziz v. Alcolac, Inc. ,
Defendant Battle Fashions is a corporation organized and existing under North Carolina law and with its principal place of business in North Carolina. (Id. at ¶ 3.) Defendant Kelsey Battle is a North Carolina resident and does business as Battle Fashions and ICAN clothing. (Id. at ¶ 4.) On January 10, 2017, Defendants sent UA a cease-and-desist letter asserting that UA was infringing on Battle's rights in the trademark "ICAN." and demanding UA "[c]ease and desist the use of the trademarks 'ICAN,' 'I CAN DO ALL THINGS,' and 'I CAN. I WILL.' and anything confusingly similar thereto." (Id. at ¶ 14.) UA responded that it uses "I can" as "part of formative and descriptive phrases," that numerous third parties use the phrase, and confusion was unlikely. (Id. at ¶ 15.)
In addition to sending Under Armour the cease-and-desist letter, Defendants wrote to third parties, including Stephen Curry, his agent, and UA's advertising agency Droga5, asserting that UA was infringing on Battle's ICAN trademark. (Id. at ¶ 7.) The letters further demanded that the third parties, given their relationships with UA, take action to preserve evidence and cease routine document destruction policies. (Id. ) UA asserts that "[t]hese third party letters were intended to and had an immediate impact on UA in Maryland." (Id. )
On November 1, 2017, almost ten months after unsuccessful negotiations, Under Armour filed this action for Declaratory Judgment, seeking a declaration that its actions have not violated the Lanham Act,
*432STANDARD OF REVIEW
A motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for lack of personal jurisdiction challenges a court's authority to exercise its jurisdiction over the moving party. Combs v. Bakker ,
If a court does not hold an evidentiary hearing or permit discovery, a plaintiff need only make "a prima facie showing of a sufficient jurisdictional basis to survive the jurisdictional challenge." Consulting Eng'rs Corp. ,
ANALYSIS
I. Personal Jurisdiction
Before a court can exercise personal jurisdiction over a non-resident defendant, a court must determine that (1) the exercise of jurisdiction is authorized under the state's long-arm statute pursuant to Rule 4(k)(1)(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure ; and (2) the exercise of jurisdiction conforms to the Fourteenth Amendment's due process requirements. Carefirst ,
Although Maryland courts "have consistently held that the state's long-arm *433statute is coextensive with the limits of personal jurisdiction set out by the Due Process Clause of the Constitution," Carefirst ,
Thus, a court may exercise two types of personal jurisdiction: " 'general' (sometimes called 'all-purpose') jurisdiction and 'specific' (sometimes called 'case-linked') jurisdiction." Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court of California, San Francisco Cty. , --- U.S. ----,
The Defendants have acknowledged in their submissions that Battle advertises its products through an internet website. (ECF No. 12-1 at 6-7.) Furthermore, it is acknowledged that this advertising led to three sales in Maryland in 2015. (Id. ) It is questionable whether such contacts can be said to be continuous and systematic contacts in Maryland to establish general jurisdiction. The real issue before this Court is whether there is specific personal jurisdiction in light of the activities of the Battle Defendants directed at Under Armour in this case.
On January 10, 2017, Defendants sent UA a cease-and-desist letter, giving rise to the case and controversy in this case,
*434(explaining that cease and desist letters do not alone allow Maryland courts to exercise personal jurisdiction over a defendant). However, Under Armour asserts in the Subject Complaint that the Battle Defendants engaged in "extra-judicial efforts" to interfere with its business activities in Maryland. It has been recognized that a court may exercise jurisdiction over a defendant when the defendant's actions go " 'beyond simply informing the plaintiff that they regarded the plaintiff's products as infringing' " and " 'interfere with the plaintiff's business by enlisting a third party to take action against the plaintiff.' " JHRG LLC v. StormWatch, Inc. , No. 1:09-cv-919,
Defendants did not only send a cease-and-desist letter to Under Armour, but also sent letters to Stephen Curry, his agent, and UA's advertising agency Droga5, asserting:
As you may or may not be aware, we are currently in a dispute with Under Armour over the use of the ICAN mark and the confusingly similar marks "I CAN DO ALL THINGS" and "I CAN. I WILL." in connection with the Steph Curry line of products. We have asked Under Armour to cease and desist from its trademark infringement ...
Given the likelihood of litigation and [your/your client's] relationship to Under Armour, we request that Steph Curry and his representatives immediately preserve all documents, materials and electronic data, including sent and received email, concerning his contractual relationship with Under Armour, the Steph Curry line of products, the use of the ICAN mark and the confusingly similar marks 'I CAN DO ALL THINGS" and "I CAN. I WILL.," and any marketing, advertising or branding strategy employing those marks.
(ECF Nos. 17-2, 17-3, 17-4.)
Defendants argue that these letters were not directed at Maryland because they were sent to California and New York. (ECF No. 17 at 6.) However, Under Armour alleges that "Battle's aim was to interfere with Under Armour's business relationships, which emanate from and are directly affected in Maryland." (ECF No. 16 at 7.) Indeed, Defendant Kelsey Battle did not name Stephen Curry, his agent, or Droga5 as defendants in the North Carolina infringement suit. See Battle v. Under Armour , Case No. 5:17-cv-00627-BO. Rather, he filed suit solely against Under Armour. These letters were efforts to notify individuals not a target of Defendant Kelsey Battle's suit that Battle was accusing Under Armour of trademark infringement, and "[g]iven the [third parties'] relationship[s] to Under Armour" the third parties needed to preserve a wide range of documents and data. (ECF Nos. 17-2, 17-3, 17-4.) Accordingly, Battle's actions went further than merely informing Under Armour of its assertion of its rights but rather allegedly took steps to interfere with Under Armour's business in Maryland. "Even a single contact may be sufficient to create jurisdiction so long as the 'principle of fair play and substantial justice is not thereby offended.' " Message Sys., Inc. v. Integrated Broadband Servs., LLC , No. CCB-09-2122,
*435II. The Declaratory Judgment Act
Defendants assert that while this Court has jurisdiction under the Declaratory Judgment Act,
Defendants assert that Under Armour engaged in forum shopping by filing this suit, and Battle's North Carolina action will clarify the legal relations at issue. UA responds that it has not engaged in forum shopping or filed an anticipatory suit, and accordingly this Court should apply the first-to-file rule. In this context, "the first-to-file rule 'gives priority, for purposes of choosing among possible venues when parallel litigation has been instituted in separate courts, to the party who first establishes jurisdiction.' " Neuralstem, Inc. v. StemCells, Inc. ,
Defendants sent UA the cease-and-desist letter in January of 2017. Defendants then claim that "while [good faith] negotiations were ongoing and days before an anticipated settlement discussion," UA filed the instant suit. (ECF No. 12-1.) However, UA did not file this action until November 1, 2017, approximately ten months after receiving Defendants' letter. Defendants then waited seven weeks before filing the North Carolina suit on December 20, 2017. Accordingly, the history of the parties' dispute does not show that UA waited until Battle's suit was "so certain or imminent," that filing suit in this Court was "an improper act of forum shopping." Mindlab Media , 838 F.Supp. at 330 (quoting Learning Network, Inc. v. Discovery Commc'ns, Inc.,
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, Defendants' Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction (ECF No. 12) is DENIED.
A separate Order follows.
Defendants assert that Battle Fashions was administratively dissolved in 2010. (ECF No. 12-1.) This Court does not reach the issue of whether Battle Fashions is a proper defendant at this time.
Battle Fashions, Inc. is not listed as a plaintiff in the North Carolina case. Currently pending in that case is Under Armour's Motion to Stay or alternatively Motion to Dismiss, given that Under Armour filed the instant suit first. The United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina has not yet ruled on the motion.
In trademark litigation, there is a case or controversy if the party seeking the declaratory judgment has been threatened with an infringement or dilution suit. TEKsystems, Inc. v. TekSavvy Solutions, Inc. , No. ELH-16-4215,
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.