Adams Communication & Engineering Technology, Inc. v. Aerovation, Inc.
Trial Court Opinion
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
Southern Division *
ADAMS COMMUNICATION &
ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY, INC., *
Plaintiff, * v. * Case No.: PWG 19-cv-3131
AEROVATION, INC., *
Defendant. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * MEMORANDUM & ORDER
Adams Communication & Engineering Technology, Inc. (“Adams”) filed suit against Aerovation, Inc. alleging breach of contract, negligence, and indemnification, related to a subcontract agreement between the companies to complete specified structural modifications on four Army aircraft in Tucson, Arizona.1 Compl., ECF No. 1; Subcontract Agmt., ECF No. 1-1. Adams, a Delaware company operating in Waldorf, Maryland, held the prime government contract with the Army. Id. It subcontracted with Aerovation, an Arizona company, to perform the work on the aircraft subject to inspection by the Army. Id. Adams alleges that the inspection revealed wiring deficiencies in the aircraft that resulted in Adams being required to engage other subcontractors to complete the modifications and repair the damage. Compl. ¶¶ 19-24.
Aerovation seeks to transfer this action to the District of Arizona pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) on the basis that the subcontract work at issue occurred in Arizona, the repair work at issue was conducted in Arizona, and almost all of the witnesses reside in Arizona. Mot., ECF No. 19.
Having reviewed the filings,2 I find that a hearing is unnecessary. See Loc. R. 105.6 (D. Md. 2018). For the reasons stated herein, Defendant’s motion is DENIED.
Congress enacted 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), which permits a district court to transfer a civil action to another district or division, “‘to prevent the waste of time, energy and money as well as to protect litigants, witnesses and the public against unnecessary inconvenience and expense.’”
Topiwala v. Wessell, No. WDQ-11-543, 2012 WL 122411, at *6 n.21 (D. Md. Jan. 12, 2012) (quoting Dicken v. United States, 862 F. Supp. 91, 92 (D. Md. 1994)). Section 1404(a) provides that, “[f]or the convenience of parties and witnesses, in the interest of justice, a district court may transfer any civil action to any other district or division where it might have been brought . . . .” In a motion to transfer venue pursuant to § 1404(a), the moving party bears the burden of showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that transfer to another venue is proper. See Costar Realty Info., Inc. v. Meissner, 604 F. Supp. 2d 757, 770 (D. Md. 2009); Lynch v. Vanderhoef Builders, 237 F. Supp. 2d 615, 617 (D. Md. 2002). Ultimately, “[t]he decision whether to transfer venue is committed to the sound discretion of the trial court.” Mamani v. Bustamante, 547 F. Supp. 2d 465, 469 (D. Md. 2008) (citing Brock v. Entre Computer Centers, Inc., 933 F.3d 1253, 1257 (4th Cir. 1991)). In the exercise of its discretion, a court should make “‘an individualized, case- by-case consideration of convenience and fairness.’” United States ex rel. Salomon v. Wolff, 268 F. Supp.3 d 770, 774 (D. Md. 2017) (quoting Stewart Org., Inc. v. Ricoh Corp., 487 U.S. 22, 29 (1988)).
The Court’s first consideration is “whether the action could have been brought in the transferee district.” Topiwala, 2012 WL 122411, at *6. Aerovation asserts, and Adams does not
Witness convenience and access is “perhaps the most important factor” to be considered.
Mamani, 547 F. Supp. 2d at 473 (quoting Cronos Containers, Ltd. v. Amazon Lines, Ltd., 121 F. Supp. 2d 461, 466 (D. Md. 2000)); see also 15 C. Wright & Miller, Fed. Practice & Procedure § 3851 (4th ed.) (“Wright & Miller”) (“The convenience of witnesses, particularly nonparty witnesses important to the resolution of the case, is often cited as the most significant factor in
In response, Adams notes that there are other important witnesses, such as personnel from the United States Army, not located in Arizona, who would similarly be required to travel if the case was transferred. Resp. 2. Adams argues that Aerovation’s affidavit is insufficient to establish hardship. Id. (citing Helsel v. Tishman Realty & Construction Co., Inc., 198 F. Supp. 2d 710, 712 (D. Md. 2002)). The Helsel court found a conclusory affidavit insufficient to satisfy the defendant’s burden of proof, stating that a party seeking to change venue must submit “‘affidavits from the witnesses and/or parties involved’ [that contain] information detailing to the court ‘why or to what extent he or she will be inconvenienced by . . . allowing the case to remain in the district where it was brought.’” 198 F. Supp. 2d at 712 (quoting Figgie Int’l, Inc. v. Destileria Serralles, Inc., 925 F. Supp. 411, 414 (D.S.C. 1996)). Although witness convenience is an important factor, this case is distinguishable from Cronos, cited by Aerovation, because neither party in Cronos had a connection to Maryland, no witnesses were in Maryland, and the case was not subject to Maryland law. See 121 F. Supp. 2d at 466. Here, there will be some inconvenience of witnesses regardless of venue, although neither party has identified the location for potential third-party witnesses, and the burden is not on Adams to show that the military personnel are not located in Arizona.4 Therefore, while this factor weighs in Aerovation’s favor, it does not weigh heavily in its favor.
With regard to the parties’ convenience, “[a] defendant moving for transfer must show both that the original forum is inconvenient for it and that the plaintiff would not be substantially inconvenienced by a transfer.” Wright & Miller § 3849. Aerovation argues that litigating in Maryland will “substantially disrupt Aerovation’s business operations” because travel is long, expensive, and would require employees to take time off work. Mot. 3. Adams notes that Aerovation did freely negotiate an agreement that recognized Maryland as a convenient venue. Resp. 2. Aerovation does not make a showing that Adams will not be inconvenienced if the case is transferred. There is no value to simply shifting the inconvenience. See Pinpoint IT Servs., L.L.C. v. Atlas IT Export Corp., 812 F. Supp. 2d 710, 721 (E.D. Va. 2011) (“[A] transfer of venue that merely switches the inconvenience from one party to the other generally will be refused.”). Further, as we have learned in recent months with all parties dealing with the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, parties can mitigate inconvenience factors to both sides through use of video depositions, and, should this case actually proceed to trial, inconvenience to witnesses located in other states may be mitigated by taking de bene esse depositions for use as trial testimony, or by having remote witnesses testify by “contemporaneous transmission from different locations.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 43(a).
Finally, the interest of justice should “‘encompass all those factors bearing on transfer that are unrelated to convenience of witnesses and parties.’” Topiwala, 2012 WL 122411, at *7
In sum, I conclude that the balance of factors does not weigh in favor of transferring this case to Arizona. For the reasons discussed, I have accorded considerable weight to Adams’ choice of forum, and Aerovation has not met its burden to counter that weight on the basis of convenience to witnesses or parties. It certainly has not tilted the balance strongly in its favor. Therefore, Defendant’s request to transfer this case shall be DENIED.
ORDER
For the foregoing reasons, it is, this 25th day of June, 2020, hereby ORDERED that Defendant’s Letter Motion to Transfer this Action to the District of Arizona (ECF No. 19) is DENIED. _____/S/_________________________
Paul W. Grimm
United States District Judge
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.