Winchester v. Union Bank
Winchester v. Union Bank
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court,
This is an action of assumpsit brought by the appellant in Baltimore County Court, as trustee of James Williams, an insolvent debtor.
The declaration contains the usual counts, for goods sold and delivered, money lent, &c., to which there is the general issue plea of non assumpsit.
The appellant claims in the character of trustee; and at the trial, for the purpose of proving his title, and right to recover, produced in evidence the papers and proceedings connected with the application and final discharge of Williams, the insolvent. By which it appears, that the bond given by the appellant for the performance of his duty as trustee, is without security, for which reason the Court below instructed the jury, that he was not entitled to recover. And it is here contended, 1st. That the certificate of the commissioners of insolvent debtors for the city and county of Baltimore, that Williams, the insolvent, had complied with all the requisitions of the insolvent laws, and his final discharge, are conclusive evidence of the regularity of the proceedings, and of the insolvency of Williams, and of the appellant’s right to sue in an action between him as trustee, and a debtor of the insolvent. 2d. That under the insolvent laws of the State, a trustee of an insolvent debtor discharged in the city of Baltimore, is not required to give bond, with security, for the faithful discharge of his duty. And 3d. That if a bond, with security, is required to be given by a trustee of an insolvent debtor, he not having given such a bond, can only be taken advantage of by a debtor of the insolvent, in a suit by the trustee, by a plea in abatement, and not on a plea of non assumpsit.
The whole of these points were raised in argument, and elaborately discussed, in the case of Houck vs. Crouse, decided by this Court at June Term, 1828, in which it
JUDGMENT AFFIRMED.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Winchester, Trustee of Williams v. The Union Bank of Maryland
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published