William v. Reynolds
William v. Reynolds
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of this court.
The correctness of the ruling on the first of the defendant’s prayers is not before us, as he did not appeal. W’e are confined to the points presented by the appeal of the children of Lucinda, against whom the defendant obtained a verdict and judgment; and these arise on the second prayer of the defendant, which the court granted, and on the second of the appellants, which was refused.
The defendant’s second prayer,- as granted, assumes that -none of the petitioners, other than Lucinda, are entitled to freedom, no matter when born, whether before or after their
But we think there was no error in refusing the second prayer of the petitioners, which asserts that such of Lucinda’s children, as were under the age of five at the time she reached twenty-seven, are entitled to their freedom. It is a mistake to suppose that they became free when their mother’s freedom commenced. Their state was made to depend on a contingency; the removal of the mother to Africa. It may have been so declared as an inducement to the mother to emigrate. If the expectation of freedom, as to these children, should be defeated, so is the wish of tbe testatrix, that her negroes should leave the State: each result is caused by the mother’s remaining here. A master may limit the time at which freedom is to commence, and it may be on a contingent event. If the event does not happen, the negro remains a slave. 8 Gill, 321. Act of 1809, ch. 171. Williams vs. Ash, 1 Howard’s Rep., 1.
In the last case, where negroes were left to a person, with the proviso that they should be free, if carried out of the State of Maryland, or sold to any one, it was held that freedom attached on the removal or sale, but that if the legatee had died before either event, the negro would have remained a slave.
For the reasons assigned, the ruling of the court is reversed pn the second prayer of the defendant, and affirmed on that of the petitioners.
Judgment reversed arid procedendo awarded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Negroes William and Others v. Edward Reynolds
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published