Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, 1863

Smith v. Montgomery

Smith v. Montgomery
Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Decided July 1, 1863 · Appleton, Barrows, Cutting, Davis, Dickerson, Kent
52 Me. 178

Counsel

A. Sanborn, for the defendant., J. A. Peters, for the plaintiff.

Smith v. Montgomery

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was drawn by

Barrows, J.

The first exception is waived by the defendant’s counsel, as plainly not tenable. Mitchell v. Clapp, 12 Cush., 378; Frohock v. Pattee, 38 Maine, 108.

With regard to the second, the allegation in this writ is not, as in Buddington v. Shearer, that the defendant was the "owner and keeper,” but simply, that he was the keeper of the dog, and this is sufficient under the statute.

The subsequent phrase, "said defendant’s dog,” must be deemed to relate to the previous allegation, and plainly means the dog of which the defendant is alleged to have been the keeper. We often speak of property temporarily in the possession of another, as his, without intending to assert that he is the owner thereof, but merely to allude to it as being in his possession or charge.

Exceptions overruled.

Appleton, C. J., Cutting, Davis, Kent and Dickerson, JJ., concurred.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.