Continental Mills v. Dow
Continental Mills v. Dow
Opinion of the Court
Complaint for costs for non-entry of an action brought by the defendant, in which the complainants were summoned as trustees.
Previous to the return day of the writ the plaintiff’s attorney notified the trustees, in writing, that the suit had been withdrawn, but they, nevertheless, seasonably filed their disclosure on the first day of the return term of the writ, and notified the plaintiff’s attorney of their readiness to submit to examination on oath. The presiding justice dismissed the complaint, and the complainants excepted.
Parties summoned as trustees are entitled to costs when they appear at the first term and disclose. This right is not contingent upon the will or action of the plaintiff, or any other conditions than those prescribed in the statute. R. S. 1857, c. 86, § 13. The complainants complied Avith the requirements of the statute, and yet it is contended that they are barred of their right to recover their costs, because the plaintiff notified them that the suit had been withdrawn. The statute certainly does not in terms, and we think it does not by implication, recognize the right of the plaintiff thus to defeat the trustee’s claim for costs. Such right is given by statute, and can be defeated only by a failure of the trustee to conform to the statute or a voluntary relinquishment of his claim.
If the plaintiff had failed to enter his action without notifying the trustees that the suit had been withdrawn, there can be no doubt but the trustees, under the facts stated, would have been entitled to costs. So if there had been a valid agreement between the plaintiff and the trustees that they should not claim costs, if the action was not entered. Hoav does the notice given change the rights and liabilities of the parties in this respect ? The trustees had no agency in suing out the AArrit; that was the voluntary act of
Exceptions sustained.
Judgment for complainant.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.