Shaw v. County Commissioners
Shaw v. County Commissioners
Opinion of the Court
Motion to dismiss an appeal from the decision of county commissioners on petition to locate a highway in an unincorporated township, because the committee was appointed too late.
The appeal was seasonably entered at the February term, 1896, when a committee was appointed. One of the committee died the following vacation, and another was appointed in his place at the next term. During the ensuing vacation that appointee declined the appointment, and another was appointed in his place at the next term, February term, 1897, when a motion to dismiss was filed and overruled and exceptions taken. A warrant to the
Inasmuch as the authority of the committee is ample and their appointment regular, we are pleased to decide the question; although if our decision were to be otherwise we could not justly do so and leave a committee required to act and incur expense with their authority revoked and no case existing where their fees and expenses could be considered.
Revised Statutes, c. 18, § 44, gives an appeal to the next Supreme Judicial Court and provides—“If the appeal is then entered, not afterwards, the court may appoint a committee of three disinterested persons, who shall be sworn, and if one of them dies, declines or becomes interested, the court shall appoint another in his place; .... they shall view the route, hear the parties, and make their report at the next or second term of the court after their appointment.”
Statutes are intended to be operative, and not inoperative. This statute intended a committee that could act, and limited the time of their report to the second term after their appointment. That appointment was finally and legally made at the February term, 1897. It could not have been made at an earlier day. There was no unnecessary delay, no inaction that the parties could have avoided. The appointment was within the express terms of the statute.
Exceptions overruled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Milton G. Shaw, and others v. County Commissioners
- Status
- Published