Inhabitants of Eden v. Pineo
Opinion of the Court
In Frenchman’s Bay, north of the village of Bar Harbor in the town of Eden, is a body of upland of about seventy acres in extent with buildings thereon. It has been known in Bar Harbor as "Rodick Island” but it is named upon the U. S. Coast Survey Chart as "Bar Island” and it is now called by either name. But it was included in the survey of the "Porcupine Islands” made in 1785 by Rufus Putnam for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and upon his plan it bears the name "Bar Porcupine.” It is something over one hundred rods distant from the shore of Mount Desert Island measuring from mean high water mark on each shore.
Is this smaller island within the chartered limits of the town of Eden ? It is conceded that it is not unless it was included within the limits of the old town of Mt. Desert from which the town of Eden was later set off. In the act incorporating the original town of Mount Desert, finally passed Feby. 17, 1789, the territory is described as follows: "The plantation called Mount Desert together with the islands called Cranberry Islands, Bartlett’s Island, Robertson’s Island and Beech Island.” No mention is made of what was then known as Bar Porcupine nor of any other island. We have no evidence of the extent of "the plantation called Mount Desert” and in the absence of such evidence we cannot assume that it comprised more than the Island of Mount Desert. Almost simultaneously with the incorporation of the town of Mount Desert, but reaching its final passage a day earlier, was incorporated the town of Gouldsboro with the following territory (after describing a tract on the main land bordering on the East of Frenchman’s Bay) "including Stave Island, Jordan’s Island, Iron Bound Island and Porcupine Islands (so called) Horn Island, Turtle Island and Scooduk Island.”
So far it would seem clear that the legislature not only did not include the seventy acre tract in question within the town of Mount Desert, but did include it within the town of Gouldsboro. Rufus Putnam, who was sent by the Commonwealth to survey the "Porcupine Islands” in Frenchman’s Bay, included this tract in his survey and plan as being one of the Porcupine Islands. This was less than four years before the acts of incorporation. The survey and plan were official and presumably were known to the legislature incorporating the two towns.
One avenue of escape from this conclusion is suggested, viz: that a body of land of the character, description and situation of
It is common knowledge that there are many islands along our coast connected with other islands by bars exposed at low water, and yet each island bearing a distinctive name, so that a deed on one, eo nomine, would not convey the other. Indeed, among these Porcupine Islands, Great Porcupine and Little Porcupine are so connected and yet appear upon the Putnam plan as distinct, separate islands. That one island is much, very much larger than the other does not extinguish the individuality of the smaller island, so long as the smaller island has itself "size and permanency enough to entitle to the appellation of island,” as is certainly the case here. One test of the individuality of this island would be to consider the case of a deed of land on the Bar Harbor side opposite, with the sidelines described as "running North to the bay,” or even
But it is urged that the legislature could not possibly have intended to leave this island out of the act of incorporation of Mount Desert. That may be conceded, but if it was in fact left out the court cannot put it in. It may be quite evident at times that the legislature of a state intended to do a thing it did not do, and did not intend to do what it did do, but it is for the legislature to correct its own errors. As said by the philosopher Hobbes "It is not wisdom but authority that makes the law.” In Bremen v. Bristol, 66 Maine, 355, the legislature was held to have in fact included in Bremen a point of land on the opposite side of the harbor, although, as the court said, it was very evident it did not intend to do so, and although it supposed and believed it was not doing so.
It appears that, nevertheless, taxes have been paid on this island for at least seventy-five years to the town of Eden by the present owners and their grantors. This, however, does not estop them from now denying that their property on the island is taxable in Eden or is within its limits. In Bremen v. Bristol, supra, it was admitted that the point of land in controversy had been taxed in Bristol since the setting off Bremen, an unusually strong case of contemporary and subsequent construction of an Act of the legislature by the parties interested, yet that fact could not change the line fixed by the legislature. The same was held in Armstrong v. Topeka, 36 Kansas, 432, 13 Pac. 843.
Neither a town nor a county can acquire jurisdiction over a territory for taxing purposes by prescription. Russell v. C. N. Robinson & Co., 153 Ala. 327, 44 So. 1040. They are the creatures of the legislature and their boundaries and jurisdiction are just what the legislature has fixed, no greater, no less, and all inconveniences and absurdities caused thereby must be borne until the legislature shall correct them. For instance, in setting off Brooksville from
Although it may have been supposed, and never before been questioned, that Bar Island was within the corporate limits of Eden, an examination of the act of incorporation of Mt. Desert in connection with the contemporaneous act incorporating Gouldsboro, (as is proper, Hamilton v. McNeil, 13 Gratten, [Va.] 389), shows that the legislature did not in fact include Bar Island in the former town, though it very likely may have intended to do so.
Unexpected as the result may be, in this . case as presented judgment must be for the defendant. It is for the legislature to correct the matter if correction be desired.
Judgment for defendant.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.