Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, 1911

Golder & McCarthy v. Butler

Golder & McCarthy v. Butler
Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Decided July 14, 1911
108 Me. 557; 82 A. 1132; 1911 Me. LEXIS 134

Golder & McCarthy v. Butler

Opinion

Assumpsit on an account annexed to recover for groceries delivered to the family of Charles Butler, the son of the defendant. Plea, the general issue. Verdict for plaintiffs for $76.49. Defendant moved for a new trial. The issue involved in this case was one of fact only. The rescript says: "The facts and testimony, as well as the circumstances, so strongly negative the plaintiffs’ claim of an original promise that the verdict should not be allowed to stand.”

Motion sustained. Verdict set aside.

McGillicuddy & Morey, for plaintiffs. W. IL Judkins, for defendant.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.