Guardianship by Stacey M.
Opinion
MAINE SUPREME JUDICIAL COURT Reporter of Decisions Decision: 2022 ME 1 Docket: Han-21-88 Submitted On Briefs: September 22, 2021 Decided: January 6, 2022 Panel: STANFILL, C.J., and MEAD, GORMAN, JABAR, HUMPHREY, and CONNORS, JJ.
GUARDIANSHIP BY STACEY M.
HUMPHREY, J.
[¶1] Stacey M. appeals from a judgment of the Hancock County Probate Court (Blaisdell, J.) denying her petition to modify or terminate an order of the Connecticut Superior Court that transferred custody and guardianship of her child to the child’s paternal grandmother and step-grandfather. Because we conclude that the Probate Court lacked subject matter jurisdiction, we vacate the judgment and remand for dismissal of the petition.
I. BACKGROUND
[¶2] The child at issue here was born in Connecticut in 2007 and was placed almost immediately in the custody of the Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF). Approximately one year later, while still in DCF’s legal custody, the child was placed with her paternal grandmother and step-grandfather in New Hampshire. On April 13, 2010, the Connecticut Superior Court held a hearing on a motion filed by the Connecticut DCF, which sought to transfer legal custody and guardianship of the child to the child’s paternal grandmother and step-grandfather. With the agreement of both parents, the court granted DCF’s motion that same day and informed the mother that she would be required to return to the Connecticut Superior Court if she sought to have her rights “reinstated.”
[¶3] In order to correct a clerical mistake, the Connecticut Superior Court issued an “Order of Custody/Guardianship” on July 8, 2010, revoking its April 13, 2010, order but simultaneously again transferring custody and guardianship to the child’s paternal grandmother and step-grandfather.1
[¶4] In 2017, the mother filed in the New Hampshire Circuit Court a petition to modify or terminate the Connecticut “Order of Custody/Guardianship.” The court denied the petition and the mother appealed. In October 2019, the New Hampshire Supreme Court determined that the New Hampshire Circuit Court lacked jurisdiction to hear the petition under New Hampshire’s Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA) and remanded to the trial court with instructions to dismiss the petition.2 See In re Guardianship of K.B., 233 A.3d 328, 329-35 (N.H. 2019).
[¶5] After the mother, the child, and the guardians had all moved to Maine, the mother filed a petition in the Hancock County Probate Court on November 22, 2019, seeking to register and modify or terminate the Connecticut order. A copy of the Connecticut order was included with the petition. Neither the mother nor the guardians challenged the Probate Court’s jurisdiction.
[¶6] After holding a two-day hearing on the merits, the Probate Court denied the mother’s petition on February 19, 2021. In its decision, the court expressed concern for the emotional turmoil experienced by the child as a result of the litigation and determined that the guardians had proved by clear and convincing evidence that the mother was unable to meet the child’s needs and that living with the mother would have a substantial adverse effect on the child. See 18-C M.R.S. § 5-210(7) (2021); see also 18-C M.R.S. § 5-204(2)(C)
II. DISCUSSION [¶7] Although the mother initiated this matter in Maine by filing her petition in the Hancock County Probate Court, she now argues on appeal that the Probate Court lacked subject matter jurisdiction because the Connecticut order was part of a child protection matter that, in Maine, would be subject to the District Court’s exclusive jurisdiction. We address this issue even though it was not raised in the trial court because “lack of subject matter jurisdiction cannot be waived and may be raised at any time.” Monteith v. Monteith, 2021 ME 40, ¶ 22, 255 A.3d 1030.
[¶8] “Subject matter jurisdiction refers to the power of a particular court to hear the type of case that is then before it.” Id. (quotation marks omitted). A court has no authority to act absent subject matter jurisdiction, and whether
[¶9] We begin by examining the nature of the Connecticut proceeding that resulted in the challenged order transferring custody and guardianship of the child to the child’s paternal grandmother and step-grandfather. The order was issued pursuant to Connecticut General Statute section 46b-129, which authorized Connecticut’s Commissioner of Children and Families to petition the Connecticut Superior Court for “appropriate action” regarding uncared-for or neglected children, including children in circumstances of abuse.4 See Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-129(a) (2011); see also Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-120(8)-(9) (2011) (defining “neglected” and “uncared for”).5 Section 46b-129 and its procedures were analogous to Maine’s child protection statutes.6 See Conn.
[¶10] “The Probate Courts in Maine are statutory courts of special and limited jurisdiction,” and they “may hear and determine only those matters authorized by statute.” In re Adoption of G., 502 A.2d 1044, 1045-46 (Me. 1986); see also In re Estate of Hiller, 2014 ME 2, ¶ 20, 86 A.3d 9 (“[W]hether the Probate Court has jurisdiction over a specific matter turns on whether a statute confers jurisdiction . . . .”). Although the Probate Court has shared jurisdiction with the District Court to appoint guardians for minors in private actions, see 4 M.R.S. § 152(5-A) (2021); 18-C M.R.S. § 5-104(1) (2021), Maine law does not provide the Probate Court with authority to order, modify, or terminate a guardianship in a child protection matter initiated through the filing of a child protection the Superior Court was required to hold a hearing on the order for temporary custody, see Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-129(f) (2011); cf. 22 M.R.S. § 4035 (2021). petition, see 18-C M.R.S. §§ 5-202, 5-204, 5-210 (2021); 22 M.R.S. § 4031(1)(A) (2021).7
[¶11] Child protection cases are distinguishable from other types of child custody matters; “the focus . . . in a child protection case is to determine whether a child requires protection in the first instance, not to determine who should have custody.” In re Higera N., 2010 ME 77, ¶ 18 n.7, 2 A.3d 265; see In re Teagan K.-O., 242 A.3d 59, 83 (Conn. 2020) (“Neglect proceedings are materially different from traditional custody disputes . . . . A state child protection agency or its commissioner is the opposing party in a neglect proceeding.”).8
[¶12] Absent any statute conferring upon it the authority to hear child protection matters, the Probate Court did not have subject matter jurisdiction
The entry is:
Judgment vacated. Remanded for dismissal of the petition.
Albert Hansen, Esq., Hansen Law Offices, PLLC, Kennebunk, for appellant Stacey M.
Eric N. Columber, Esq., Columber Law Offices, Ellsworth, for appellees paternal grandmother and step-grandfather Hancock County Probate Court docket number 2019-477 FOR CLERK REFERENCE ONLY (Conn. 2002) (holding that adjudications of neglect pursuant to Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-129 fall under the jurisdiction of Connecticut’s Superior Court, not its Probate Court).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.