Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney v. Recorder's Court Judge

Michigan Court of Appeals
Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney v. Recorder's Court Judge, 209 N.W.2d 610 (1973)
47 Mich. App. 615; 1973 Mich. App. LEXIS 1339
Quinn, McGregor, Bronson

Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney v. Recorder's Court Judge

Opinion

Per Curiam.

In these causes a complaint for superintending control and motion for order to show cause are filed by plaintiff, and answers in opposition thereto having been filed, and due consideration thereof having been had by the Court.

It is ordered that the motion for order to show cause be, and the same is hereby denied for lack of meritorious grounds for the relief sought. In Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, 386 Mich 672 (1972), the Supreme Court held that the conduct of the prosecution is an executive act and that the circuit judge exceeded her jurisdiction and usurped the executive function of the prosecutor when she determined, over the objection of the prosecutor, under which of two admittedly applicable statutes a prosecution would be conducted where neither statute was a lesser included offense of the other. This decision cannot be applied in the instant case. The crime of murder in the second degree to which the Recorder’s Court Judge permitted defendants Brown and Morgan to plead guilty is a lesser included offense of murder in the first degree, the crime charged in this case, based on the facts which appear in the record. The Supreme Court specifically excluded this situation from its holding in Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, supra, 386 Mich 672, 684. The prosecutor’s reliance on the foregoing case is therefore misplaced. We find no authority supporting the proposition that the circuit judge has no jurisdiction to accept a plea of guilty to a lesser included offense of the crime charged. The complaint for superintending control is therefore dismissed.

Reference

Full Case Name
WAYNE COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY v. RECORDER’S COURT JUDGE; In Re PEOPLE v. MORGAN; In Re PEOPLE v. BROWN
Cited By
3 cases
Status
Published