Court of Appeals, State of Michigan ORDER Kirsten Frank Kelly Daniel W Rudd v City of Norton Shores Presiding Judge Docket No. 343759; 344727 Karen M. Fort Hood LC No. 17-004334-CZ James Robert Redford Judges

The Court orders that the June 18, 2019 opinion is hereby AMENDED. The opinion contained the following clerical error: Page five, last paragraph, third sentence is corrected to read : Further, once it decided that the complaints were not exemptible as personnel records despite defendant's labeling them as such, the trial court did not have to conduct the public-interest balancing test.

In all other respects, the June 18, 2019 opinion remains unchanged.

A true copy entered and certified by Jerome W. Zimmer Jr. , Chief Clerk, on

JUN 2 6 2019 Date