Eldridge v. Bliss
Opinion of the Court
In January, 1867, Bliss caused to be conveyed to Eldridge certain real estate, which was received as a payment of $3,500 upon an existing debt. At the same time, Eldridge received of Bliss an agreement whereby he covenanted to pay all taxes upon the land while Eldridge and his heirs should hold it, and -also covenanted that if, upon the sale of the property, Eldridge should not clear $3,500 and interest, over and above expenses, he would pay enough to make good that amount.
No attempt was made by Eldridge to dispose of the property until the time presently to be referred to. In August, 1868, Eldridge had an offer through Bliss of $3,700, payable one quarter down and the balance in two years, with interest at 7 per cent. He declined this and refused to take less than $3,800, payable one quarter down and the remainder in one, two, and three years, with interest at 10 per cent. This proposal was not accepted.
November 33d, 1868, Eldridge wrote to an agent in East Saginaw, directing him, in case Bliss was good, to sell the property at auction, after reasonable time or notice, and if the property brought less than than $3,500 to enforce the
The agent, after notifying Bliss, and offering to convey to him or any one whom he might appoint, on payment of the $2,500, with interest and taxes, advertised it on the 12th of December, 1868, for sale on the 19th. On the 16th of December Bliss protested in writing against the sale for less than $2,700, and declared he would not be responsible for any balance if so sold. The sale was afterwards, at his request, adjourned one week, and then the premises were sold for $1,535. The sale was fairly conducted. It is found that every year at that time there is a scarcity of money in that portion of the State.
Bliss is sued for the deficiency, and for some small amounts paid for taxes and expenses of sale.
The Circuit Court gave judgment for the taxes, but not for the deficiency, holding that the sale was not justified by the contract, under the circumstances, and that the covenant to pay taxes was independent of the conditions relating to the sale.
We think the covenant to pay the taxes was a separate covenant, and that its breach could have no effect on the conditions relating to the land and its proceeds. The agreement to refund the deficiency on sale referred only to making up what should be wanting to raise $2,500, and interest, clear of expenses of sale.
The principal question, however, relates to the right of Eldridge to sell when and in the manner he did, and to the liability of Bliss to make up the deficiency.
To determine this it is necessary to look at the contract.
We are very strongly inclined to regard the refusal to sell for $3,700, when it was offered, as estopping Eldridge from making any claim for deficiency under a subsequent sale for a less amount. Without deciding that he had no right to sell, except on the usual terms of part cash and part credit, it is quite evident, and is so found, that he would have done so if the price and rate of interest were satisfactory. The subsequent- proceedings, in the light of his instructions, manifested a disposition to force a sale when he expressly expected and designed to risk a sacrifice which would not result if he waited longer. He had delayed when he could have sold profitably; and when a sale was not expedient, he sacrificed the property for less than two thirds of its value. His position was one which involved relations of a fiduciary nature, and his action was not such as it should have been. But we are relieved from the necessity of determining the precise extent of his powers to sell, because, in any event, he was bound, if he sold at auction for cash, to give reason
The judgment must be affirmed with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.