Altman v. Young
Altman v. Young
Opinion of the Court
This is an action of assumpsit for goods sold brought before a justice and appealed by Mrs. Altman, the defendant, to the circuit, where judgment was also rendered against her. She brings error.
On the trial upon the merits, as appears from the record, several questions came up which will be presently considered. We do not understand how the denial of a motion to dismiss an appeal can be made the ground of an exception, and we shall not consider that question.
Several questions were asked Mrs.. Altman and her husband on cross-examination concerning their habit .of purchasing and doing business. As the chief issue
As we are not informed why the reading of the justice’s return was objected to, we are unable to say it was incompetent. It was part of the record.
A witness (Benfey) was asked whether certain goods were identical with those mentioned in the bill on file. As the identity of the goods was in issue, we can see no reason why this was not a proper course, and the objection does not seem to be relied on upon the argument filed.
The alleged errors in the judge’s finding were not excepted to.
There is no error in the record, and the judgment must be affirmed with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ida Altman v. Isaac S. Young
- Status
- Published