Michigan Supreme Court, 1885

People v. Luby

People v. Luby
Michigan Supreme Court · Decided April 29, 1885 · Cooley, Other
56 Mich. 551; 23 N.W. 218; 1885 Mich. LEXIS 705

People v. Luby

Opinion of the Court

Cooley, C. J.

The respondent was convicted in the Recorder’s Court of Kalamazoo of a criminal assault and battery, on a trial by a jury of six. He demanded a jury of twelve.

Twelve is the constitutional number of jurors in this State. Hill v. People 16 Mich. 351. The Constitution makes an exception for courts not of record (Art. 6, § 28); but by the statute creating the Recorder’s Court of Kalamazoo, it is expressly declared to be a court of record. Local Acts 1883, [No. 337], pp. 677, 694. It does not therefore come within the exception.

The conviction must be quashed.

The other Justices concurred.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.