Sinnook v. Hosmer
Sinnook v. Hosmer
Opinion of the Court
Relators commenced a suit in the Wayne circuit court by declaration. Defendants entered their appearance, but their default was taken and made absolute for want of a plea. On September 21, 1893, plaintiffs served upon the attorneys for defendants a notice of the assessment of damages by the court for October 6, 1893. On October 6 defendants appeared, and objected to the assessment of damages, on the ground that' the notice for
Section 7551 of the statutes provides for written notice of trial of every issue of fact. There was, however, no issue framed or made. To constitute an issue, there must be both affirmance and denial.
Section 4 (How. Stat. § 7647) of chapter 265 of the statutes provides that, in case of an appearance, “the like notice of assessment of damages by the clerk shall be given as is required of the trial of a cause.” Section 15 (How. Stat. § 7658) of the same chapter provides #that in all other suits wherein, by the preceding provisions, the clerk is not authorized to assess the damages, they may be assessed by a jury. Our statutes contain no other provisions regulating the practice in case damages are to be assessed by court or jury. We think it is clear that section 15 (7658) must be construed in connection with section 4, and must be considered as requiring the same notice in case of an assessment other than by the clerk as is required by section 4 (7647). Sections 1 to 14 of this chapter are taken from the N. Y. Statute (2 Rev. Stat. N Y. 1836, 280). Section 15 of our statute does not appear in the New York statute. Under that statute, damages were assessed upon a writ of inquiry, and the practice relating to such writ was fixed by statute or rule, as under the English practice. The writ of inquiry is unknown in our practice.
But does the language, “like notice as is required of the trial of a cause,” signify that the notice of assessment of damages must be a notice for the first day of the term
The writ must issue as prayed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William P. Sinnook and Horace D. Sherrill v. George S. Hosmer, Circuit Judge of Wayne County
- Status
- Published