Ocobock v. Myers' Estate
Ocobock v. Myers' Estate
Opinion of the Court
The claimant recovered a verdict for $548.14 on a claim based upon a note made by deceased in March, 1881. The question in the case was whether the statute of limitations had run against the note. The questions of law involved are not numerous.
It is contended by the counsel for the estate that the indorsements were received in evidence, and that this was error. The record does not indicate very clearly that the circuit j udge at any time intended to receive the indorsements. The record shows that the note was offered in
“In this case there is no proof that the indorsements appearing on the note were placed there by the direction or with the consent of the maker of the note. Such indorsements are no evidence that any payments were made by the maker of the note, as it is not shown that Myers ever knew of their being made, or that he ever made a payment to apply on this identical note. If entered by the claimant on the note, such entry or indorsement is not evidence, and not even a circumstance, that the maker of the note made payments, unless claimant has shown that the payments were made by the maker to apply on the note, and directed the claimant to indorse them on the note, which you are instructed he has not done.”
It is clear, therefore, that the jury were not permitted' at any stage of the proceedings to regard these indorsements as evidence of payments, and the allegatidn of error in that regard-must be overruled.
It is also contended that the evidence of payments on the note was incomplete, as the testimony of the witnesses did not identify the note in suit as that upon which the payments were made. The. note was not present when the payments were made. The evidence, however, is directed to the point that the payments were made upon a note held by claimant. There was no evidence that he. held any other note against decedent, and there is some
We find no error. Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- OCOBOCK v. MYERS' ESTATE
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published