Bigelow v. Thompson
Bigelow v. Thompson
Opinion of the Court
The bill in this cause was filed by the grantor in a quitclaim deed of timber, to have it declared a mortgage and for an accounting, and to enjoin the grantee from cutting the timber. The defendant has appealed from a decree granting the prayer of the bill.
We are urged to reverse this decree upon the ground that the evidence that the deed was intended as security was not clear and convincing. While it is true that the defendant denies complainant’s statement of the transaction, we think the circumstances tend to support the complainant’s testimony, and that we should not disturb the finding of the circuit judge upon this point. He saw the witnesses, and the evidence may have been very convincing. We are satisfied that it clearly preponderates in complainant’s favor.
The result reached by the learned circuit judge is, in •our opinion, justified by the testimony, and his decree is affirmed, with costs.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.