The printed record affords no evidence that a judgment in this cause was ever entered. An ex-*393animation of the return to the writ of error discloses the fact that the case has not proceeded to judgment. A verdict was directed, and a motion to set it aside and grant a new trial was denied. No further proceedings, except to settle a bill of exceptions, appear to have been had.

The writ of error is dismissed, with costs to appellee. Delaney v. Lumber Co., 144 Mich. 351.