Bresnahan v. Cass Circuit Judge
Bresnahan v. Cass Circuit Judge
Opinion of the Court
This is an application for a mandamus requiring the respondent to set aside an order directing a change of venue in the case of People v. Frank W. Lyle and Ira B. Gage, based upon two counts: First, that the order was prematurely made, it having been entered before the case was at issue; and, second, upon the ground that there was an abuse of discretion in awarding the change of venue.
A preliminary question is raised by the respondent, namely, that no motion was regularly entered asking the
The principal question is whether it was proper to enter the order before the cause was at issue. The statute, as amended in 1907 (Act No. 161, Pub. Acts 1907), reads in part as follows:
“ Each of the said courts, upon good cause shown, may change the venue in any cause pending therein, and direct the issue to be tried in the circuit court of another county, and make all necessary rules and orders for the certifying and removing such cause, and all matters relating thereto, to the court in which such issue shall be ordered to be tried, and the court to which such cause shall be so removed shall proceed to hear, try and determine the same.”
This statute plainly imports that what is to be transferred from one county to another is a case at issue, as it refers to the court to which the case is transferred as the court in which such issue shall be ordered to be tried, and the duty of that court to which the cause is transferred is defined, namely, to proceed to hear, try, and determine the same. There is abundant reason for this. The ground of the application for a change of venue of the present case is the claim that it would be impossible to secure a jury. Unless an issue of fact is made, no jury will be called upon to act in the case. Hence no necessity for a change of venue.
Cases are not numerous in which this question has
The order for a change of venue should be set aside.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- BRESNAHAN v. CASS CIRCUIT JUDGE
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published