People ex rel. People's State Bank v. O'Connell
People ex rel. People's State Bank v. O'Connell
Opinion of the Court
This action was brought by the above named bank against defendants O’Connell and Murray, as sureties on the official bond of Stuart B. Nicol, drain commissioner of Sanilac county, to recover
Drain Commissioner Nicol died in December, 1918. When the orders fell due on March 15, 1919, their payment by the county treasurer had been enjoined by the chancery court, because unlawfully issued, and Davis had turned out to be uncollectible. This action was thereafter soon begun and trial had before the court without a jury. The facts were practically undisputed. Findings of fact with conclusions of law thereon were filed. Plaintiff was awarded judgment in the sum of $3,124.25, being the amount it actually paid for the void orders, with interest at 5% thereon.
About the time this case was submitted an opinion was handed down in a similar case heard the preceding term, entitled People, for use of Lapeer County Bank, v. O’Connell, 214 Mich. 410. Both cases are against Nicol’s bondsmen, based on illegal drain orders
The trial court found that the purchase of those orders was made in good faith and full consideration paid for them by the bank. This finding is well supported by competent testimony. The opinion in the Lapeer County Bank Case by Justice Stone, filed June 6, 1921, carefully reviews on a similar state of facts the important questions involved here and is controlling.
The judgment is affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- PEOPLE, for use of PEOPLE'S STATE BANK v. O'CONNELL
- Status
- Published