Minnesota Court of Appeals, 1984 The Minnesota Court of Appeals held that a fatal shooting during a robbery to steal the victim's van arose out of the van's use, entitling his widow to no-fault basic economic loss benefits.

The Minnesota Court of Appeals held that a fatal shooting during a robbery to steal the victim's van arose out of the van's use, entitling his widow to no-fault basic economic loss benefits.

Meric v. Mid-Century Insurance Co.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · Decided February 1, 1984 · No. C6-83-1460 · Heard
343 N.W.2d 688; 44 A.L.R. 4th 1005; 1984 Minn. App. LEXIS 2999 (North Western Reporter, Second Series)

Outcome: Affirmed for plaintiff.

AI-enhanced analysis. Verify before relying in legal proceedings.

Counsel

Eric J. Magnuson, Rider, Bennett, Egan & Arundel, Minneapolis, for appellant., Eric B. Nilsson, Briggs & Morgan, P.A., St. Paul, for respondent.

Can I rely on this case?

Citation treatment has not been reviewed for this case. The notes below come from the citation graph and the Minnesota Revisor's amendment records, not from a review of how later courts treated this decision.

(as of 9/30/2026)

Last cited by a Minnesota appellate court in 1996, among the opinions in this site’s citation index.

Cites Minnesota statutes amended since this decision

Amendment history from the Minnesota Revisor of Statutes. A later amendment does not necessarily affect this decision's analysis — check the current statute text.

Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

See our Terms of Use before relying on these notes. Report an error

Meric v. Mid-Century Insurance Co.

What happened

The facts of the case, in plain language.

Luis Meric-Acevedo, a Minnesota resident, was shot and mortally wounded in Winnipeg, Canada by a robber who used his van as an escape vehicle after a struggle.

Mid-Century Insurance Company denied the widow's claim for basic economic loss benefits because, in its view, the death did not arise out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle.

Under Minn.Stat. § 65B.46(2), insureds and their surviving dependents suffering loss from injury arising out of maintenance or use of a motor vehicle in Canada have a right to basic economic loss benefits.

The court concluded the van was an active accessory to the death because the robber shot Meric-Acevedo to commandeer the van, and the assault would not have occurred had he been on foot.

The parties filed cross motions for summary judgment, and the municipal court granted Ms. Meric's motion in an August 8, 1983 order; the insurance company appealed.

What the court decided

Luis Meric-Acevedo, a Minnesota resident traveling in Canada with two bandmates to perform, was shot and killed by a robber who seized his slowly rolling van as a getaway vehicle. His widow claimed basic economic loss benefits as a survivor under their Minnesota no-fault automobile policy, but Mid-Century Insurance Company denied the claim because the death did not, in its view, arise out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle. After the parties filed cross motions for summary judgment, the municipal court granted the widow's motion, and the insurer appealed. Applying the standard that an injury must be causally connected to the vehicle's use for transportation purposes—something less than proximate cause but more than the vehicle being a mere situs—the court found the van an active accessory: the robber shot Meric-Acevedo because he wanted the van, and the assault would not have occurred had he been on foot. Affirmed.

  1. For an injury to arise out of the 'use' of a motor vehicle under Minnesota's no-fault act, the injury must be causally connected with the vehicle's use for transportation purposes—a connection something less than proximate cause in the tort sense and something more than the vehicle being the mere situs of the injury. (*690)
  2. A motor vehicle is an 'active accessory' to an injury, and the injury arises out of the vehicle's use, when the injury would not have occurred but for the assailant's desire to obtain the vehicle itself—as where a victim is shot for refusing to surrender the vehicle to a robber who then uses it to flee. (*690)
  3. An act of independent significance—such as the tortfeasor leaving the vehicle before inflicting a battery—breaks the causal link between the vehicle's use and the injury and defeats no-fault coverage, whereas injuries inflicted in direct furtherance of obtaining or using the vehicle retain that link. (*690)
  4. Insureds and their surviving dependents who suffer loss from injury arising out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle have a right to basic economic loss benefits under Minn.Stat. § 65B.46(2) even when the accident occurs outside Minnesota, including in Canada.

How the court reached its decision

The court's reasoning, step by step.

Whether Mr. Meric-Acevedo's death arose out of the use of his van, permitting his widow to collect no-fault basic economic loss benefits. The robber shot Mr. Meric-Acevedo because he wanted the slowly rolling van as a getaway vehicle and Meric-Acevedo refused to surrender it; the assault would not have occurred had he been on foot, and no act of independent significance broke the causal link between the van's use and the death. Because the death resulted from the van's use as a vehicle, the no-fault act applies, basic economic loss benefits are due the widow, and the municipal court's grant of summary judgment to her is affirmed.

Whether any precedent permits no-fault recovery for injuries inflicted in assaults connected to a vehicle, as the appellant contended none existed. In Mann, a plaintiff injured when a rock was thrown at his car from a freeway overpass recovered because the assault was causally linked to driving—he would not have been assaulted had he not been driving—and the same causal logic applies to the assault on Mr. Meric-Acevedo. Precedent exists for assault-related no-fault recovery, refuting the appellant's categorical objection and supporting coverage for the robbery-related shooting.

Key quotes from the opinion

Notable passages from the opinion, in the court's own words.

“The injury must, however, be causally connected with the use of the vehicle for transportation purposes.”
Threshold requirement for no-fault coverage: causal connection to transportation use — *690
“something less than proximate cause in the tort sense and something moré than the vehicle being the mere situs of the injury”
Degree of causal connection required under the arising-out-of-use test — *690
“No act of independent significance broke the causal link between use as a vehicle and Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s death; the van was, therefore, an active accessory in the death.”
Court's application of the test: van as active accessory to the shooting — *690
“Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s death resulted from the use of his van as a vehicle. He was shot because the robber wanted to commandeer the van. Had he not been in the van, he would not have been shot.”
Decision rationale supporting award of basic economic loss benefits — *691

Cases the court relied on

Earlier decisions the court cited as authority for its ruling.

  • Haagenson v. National Farmers Union Property & Casualty Co. (277 N.W.2d 648) — Supplies the foundational requirement that a no-fault injury be causally connected with the vehicle's use for transportation purposes.
  • Tlougan v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co. (310 N.W.2d 116) — Provides the measure of the required connection—something less than proximate cause in the tort sense and something more than the vehicle being the mere situs of the injury.
  • Holm v. Mutual Service Casualty Insurance Co. (261 N.W.2d 598) — Source of the 'active accessory' requirement and the contrasting case in which an officer who left his squad car before inflicting a battery defeated coverage; the court distinguishes the present robbery, where no independent act intervened.
  • Mann v. Detroit Automobile Inter-Insurance Exchange (314 N.W.2d 719) — Michigan precedent allowing no-fault recovery for a freeway rock-throwing assault causally linked to driving, cited to rebut the appellant's claim that no cases permit assault-related recovery.
  • Kangas v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. (235 N.W.2d 42) — Primary case in the line relied on by the appellant holding that acts of independent significance break the causal link between vehicle use and injury; also cited for Michigan's stricter foreseeability standard.

Minnesota statutes cited

Sections of the Minnesota Statutes this opinion cites.

Cases that cite this one

13 later published cases cite this decision.

This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

Full opinion

The complete text of the court's opinion as published.

Opinion

OPINION

PARKER, Judge.

Luis Meric-Acevedo’s widow was denied basic economic loss benefits by her no-fault insurance carrier. She filed this suit to compel the insurance company to pay those benefits. The parties filed cross motions for summary judgment. The municipal court granted Ms. Meric’s motion in an August 8, 1983 order. The insurance company appeals.

FACTS

Luis Meric-Acevedo, a Minnesota resident, and two other members of the band “Bread, Cheese and Wine” drove to Winnipeg, Canada to perform. They arrived in Winnipeg and stopped to buy beer at the Montcalm Motor Hotel before joining the rest of the band. The two band members with Mr. Meric-Acevedo got out of the van to buy the beer. Mr. Meric-Acevedo stayed with the van and waited for them.

At the same time that the band members were getting their beer, Roy Hoffman was robbing the motor hotel. Seeing Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s van slowly rolling up to the motor hotel entrance, Mr. Hoffman saw his escape. He walked up to the van, opened the door, pointed his gun and ordered Mr. Meric-Acevedo out of the van. A struggle ensued. The gun fired. Mr. Meric-Aceve-do fell to the pavement mortally wounded; the van, still in gear, rolled away, pursued by the robber. The robber then fled in the van.

Ms. Meric, the decedent’s wife, filed for basic economic loss benefits as a survivor under their Minnesota no-fault automobile insurance plan issued by Mid-Century Insurance Company. Mid-Century denied the claim because, in their view, his death did not arise out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle.

ISSUE

Did Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s death arise out of the use of an automobile, thereby allowing his widow to collect no-fault insurance benefits?

ANALYSIS

Eligibility for basic economic benefits under Minnesota’s no-fault insurance plan is governed by the “Right to Benefits” section of the statute:

If the accident causing injury occurs outside this state in the United States, United States possessions, or Canada, the following persons and their surviving dependents suffering loss from injury arising out of maintenance or use of a motor vehicle have a right to basic economic loss benefits:
(1) Insureds * * ⅞

Minn.Stat. § 65B.46(2) (1982).

Generally, “use” has a broader meaning than driving or operating an automobile. Uniform Motor Vehicle Accident Reparations Act § 1(a)(6) comment (1982). The injury must, however, be causally connected with the use of the vehicle for transportation purposes. Haagenson v. National Farmers Union Property and Cas. Co., 277 N.W.2d 648 (Minn. 1979). The connection required is “something less than proximate cause in the tort sense and something moré than the vehicle being the mere situs of the injury.” Tlougan v. Auto-Owners *690 Ins. Co., 310 N.W.2d 116, 117 (Minn. 1981). As noted in Holm v. Mutual Service Cas. Ins. Co., 261 N.W.2d 598 (Minn. 1977), “the vehicle itself must be an active accessory” to the injury. Id. at 603 (quoting National Mut. Cas. Co. v. Clark, 193 Miss. 27, 40, 7 So.2d 800, 805 (1942)).

In Holm, a police officer chased a motorcyclist. To escape, the cyclist went up a steep hill and dismounted. The officer followed in his squad car, stopped at the top, and got out to arrest the cyclist. During the arrest, the cyclist was injured. He sued. The Minnesota Supreme Court refused to allow no-fault benefits because the use of the police car was unrelated to the cyclist’s injuries, noting:

Converse [the police officer] had completely left the vehicle before he administered the tortious battery. The police car had served only to transport him to the scene of the incident. The battery could as easily have occurred had Converse come upon the stationary motorcycle while on foot.

Id. at 603. The court cited cases, including Rangas v. Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 64 Mich. App. 1, 235 N.W.2d 42 (1975), the primary case in a line of cases relied on by the appellant, which denied no-fault benefits to assault victims because:

[i]n each of these decisions the acts of leaving the vehicle and inflicting a battery were viewed as events of independent significance which broke the causal link between the “use” of the vehicle and the injuries inflicted. And this was so in spite of the fact that in each instance the subject auto was used to transport the tortfeasor(s) to the scene of the incident. Read together, the cases fully support the general proposition that for an injury to “arise out of the use” of an automobile it must be causally related to the employment of the vehicle for transportation purposes. In the words of the National Mutual court, “the vehicle itself must be an active accessory” to the injury sustained. (Italics supplied.) National Mut. Cas. Co. v. Clark, 193 Miss. 40, 7 So.2d 805.

Holm, 261 N.W.2d at 603 (Minn. 1977). In the present case, the assault would not have occurred had not the robber wanted the van as transportation. Because Mr. Meric-Acevedo was using the vehicle and refused to surrender it, the robber shot Mr. Meric-Acevedo and stole the vehicle, using it for his attempted get-away. The assault would not have happened if Mr. Meric-Acevedo had been on foot. No act of independent significance broke the causal link between use as a vehicle and Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s death; the van was, therefore, an active accessory in the death.

The appellant claims that no cases allow no-fault recovery for an assault related to a vehicle. Even in Michigan, however, where a closer causal connection is required than in Minnesota, 1 cases have allowed no-fault recovery for assaults. Saunders v. Detroit Auto. Inter-Ins. Exchange, 123 Mich. App. 570, 332 N.W.2d 613 (1983); Mann v. Detroit Auto. Inter-Ins. Exchange, 111 Mich.App. 637, 314 N.W.2d 719 (1981). In Mann, a plaintiff was injured when a rock was thrown at his car from a freeway overpass. The court found a causal link between the assault and driving the car: “if the plaintiff had not been driving his automobile, he would not have been assaulted. Injuries sustained as a result of an assault, therefore, arise out of the operation and use of the motor vehicle as a motor vehicle.” Id. 314 N.W.2d at 720. The same can be said for the assault on Mr. Meric-Acevedo.

DECISION

Mr. Meric-Acevedo’s death resulted from the use of his van as a vehicle. He was shot because the robber wanted to commandeer the van. Had he not been in the van, he would not have been shot. The *691 no-fault act applies and basic economic loss benefits are due his widow.

Affirmed.

SEDGWICK, J., took no part in the consideration or decision of this case.
1

. Michigan requires that the injury must be "foreseeably identifiable with the normal use, maintenance and ownership of the vehicle." Kangas v. Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 64 Mich.App. 1, 17, 235 N.W.2d 42, 50 (1975).

This page includes AI-generated summaries and analysis based on the full opinion text and citing cases. We believe the summaries are accurate, but you should always verify the holdings, quotes, and treatment data against the original opinion before relying on them in legal proceedings.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.