Minnesota Court of Appeals, 1984 A Minnesota appellate court held that a judgment voluntarily paid and satisfied of record ceases to exist, leaving the trial court without subject matter jurisdiction to vacate it under Rule 60.02(1).

A Minnesota appellate court held that a judgment voluntarily paid and satisfied of record ceases to exist, leaving the trial court without subject matter jurisdiction to vacate it under Rule 60.02(1).

Boulevard Del, Inc. v. Stillman
Minnesota Court of Appeals · Decided January 25, 1984 · No. CX-83-1283 · Heard
343 N.W.2d 50; 1984 Minn. App. LEXIS 2995 (North Western Reporter, Second Series)

Outcome: Reversed for appellant.

AI-enhanced analysis. Verify before relying in legal proceedings.

Counsel

Leo Dorfman, Minneapolis, for appellant., Lawrence T. Hofmann, Minneapolis, for Marvin Stillman, defendant & third party plaintiff, respondent, and Arthur Mack, et ah, third party defendants.

Can I rely on this case?

Citation treatment has not been reviewed for this case. The notes below come from the citation graph and the Minnesota Revisor's amendment records, not from a review of how later courts treated this decision.

(as of 9/30/2026)

Last cited by a Minnesota appellate court in 2005, among the opinions in this site’s citation index.

Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

See our Terms of Use before relying on these notes. Report an error

Boulevard Del, Inc. v. Stillman

What happened

The facts of the case, in plain language.

Defendant fully paid the judgment within nine days after entry of summary judgment, satisfaction of the judgment was filed, and the judgment was discharged of record.

Stillman did not appeal the summary judgment order and did not request a stay of entry or a stay of execution before voluntarily paying the judgment in full.

Between commencement of the action and the hearing on the summary judgment motion, defendant took no depositions, obtained no opposing affidavits, and conducted no other discovery.

The only evidence opposing the summary judgment motion was an affidavit by defendant's attorney reciting, on information and belief, that plaintiff failed to perform certain obligations under the guarantee agreement.

Since receiving the money from defendant, plaintiff paid income taxes, estate taxes, and attorney's fees for obtaining the judgment, which the court found established substantial prejudice from vacation of the judgment.

What the court decided

Boulevard Del sued Stillman in January 1983 to recover $25,000 under a lease guarantee and obtained summary judgment after Stillman opposed only with his attorney's information-and-belief affidavit, having conducted no discovery. Within nine days of entry, Stillman paid the judgment in full and satisfaction was filed; ten weeks later he moved under Minn.R.Civ.P. 60.02(1) to vacate the judgment as excusable attorney neglect, and another district judge set aside the summary judgment. The Court of Appeals reversed. It held that a judgment paid and satisfied of record ceases to exist, leaving nothing to vacate, so the trial court lacked subject matter jurisdiction. Even apart from that defect, Stillman failed all four Finden v. Klaas conditions for setting aside a summary judgment—reasonable defense, reasonable excuse, diligence, and absence of substantial prejudice—and the reversal was without prejudice to his third-party action.

  1. A judgment that has been paid in full and satisfied of record ceases to have any existence, leaving nothing to vacate; a district court therefore lacks subject matter jurisdiction to vacate it under Minn.R.Civ.P. 60.02(1). (*52)
  2. To set aside a summary judgment, the moving party must possess a reasonable defense on the merits, have a reasonable excuse for the failure or neglect involved, have acted with due diligence after notice of the entry of judgment, and show that no substantial prejudice will result to the other party. (*53)
  3. An affidavit opposing summary judgment must be made on personal knowledge and present specific facts showing a genuine issue for trial; an attorney's affidavit reciting facts on information and belief is not proper evidence under Minn.R.Civ.P. 56.05. (*53)

How the court reached its decision

The court's reasoning, step by step.

Whether a district court has subject matter jurisdiction to vacate a judgment that has been paid in full and satisfied of record. Stillman neither appealed the summary judgment nor requested a stay of entry or a stay of execution; within nine days of entry he voluntarily paid the judgment in full, satisfaction was filed, and the judgment was discharged of record—all some ten weeks before he moved under Rule 60.02(1) to vacate. Because the judgment ceased to exist upon payment and satisfaction of record, the trial court had no subject matter jurisdiction to vacate it.

Whether the district court abused its discretion in vacating the summary judgment for excusable attorney neglect under Rule 60.02(1). Defendant conducted no discovery before the summary judgment hearing, offered only his attorney's information-and-belief affidavit, made no effort to obtain affidavits or deposition testimony from witnesses he knew long beforehand possessed relevant personal knowledge, filed no Rule 56.06 affidavit stating reasons why a continuance was needed, and plaintiff had already paid income taxes, estate taxes, and attorney's fees out of the judgment proceeds, establishing substantial prejudice. Defendant failed all four Finden conditions; apart from the lack of subject matter jurisdiction, the district court abused its discretion in vacating the summary judgment, and the order was reversed without prejudice to defendant's third-party action.

Key quotes from the opinion

Notable passages from the opinion, in the court's own words.

“we hold that a judgment which is paid and satisfied of record ceases to have any existence”
Central holding: a judgment paid and satisfied of record leaves nothing to vacate — *52
“When a motion for summary judgment is made and supported as provided in Rule 56, an adverse party may not rest upon the mere averments or denials of his pleading but must present specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial. If he does not so respond, summary judgment, if appropriate, shall be entered against him.”
Text of Minn.R.Civ.P. 56.05 requiring specific facts in opposition to summary judgment — *52
“To set aside a summary judgment, the moving party must meet four conditions. The party must (1) possess a reasonable defense on the merits, (2) have a reasonable excuse for the failure or neglect involved, (3) have acted with due diligence after notice of the entry of judgment, and (4) show that no substantial prejudice will result to the other party.”
Finden v. Klaas four conditions for setting aside a summary judgment — *53
“The evidence shows that long before the summary judgment motion was heard, defendant knew who had personal knowledge of facts which might support triable issues of fact, yet no effort was made to obtain their deposition testimony or affidavits.”
Defendant's failure to obtain affidavits or depositions from known witnesses despite advance knowledge — *53

Cases the court relied on

Earlier decisions the court cited as authority for its ruling.

  • Finden v. Klaas (268 Minn. 268, 128 N.W.2d 748) — Supplies the four-condition test—reasonable defense, reasonable excuse, due diligence, and absence of substantial prejudice—that governs motions to set aside a summary judgment and that the defendant failed in full.
  • Bartel v. New Haven Tp. (323 N.W.2d 806) — Established that voluntary payment of a judgment during a stay of entry extinguishes the right to appeal; the court drew on that principle to conclude that payment and satisfaction of record after entry, without appeal or stay, leaves nothing to vacate.
  • Gaspord v. Washington County Planning Commission (312 Minn. 591, 252 N.W.2d 590) — States the general standard that summary judgment is appropriate where no material fact issues remain for trial and determination of the applicable law will resolve the controversy.

Cases that cite this one

20 later published cases cite this decision.

This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

Full opinion

The complete text of the court's opinion as published.

Opinion

OPINION

FOLEY, Judge.

This is an appeal from an order vacating a summary judgment in favor of plaintiff, after payment and satisfaction of the judgment. We reverse.

Facts

Plaintiff-appellant, Boulevard Del commenced an action against defendant-respondent, Stillman to recover $25,000 under a lease guarantee in January of 1983. Subsequently, Boulevard Del filed a motion for summary judgment. Between the commencement of the action and a hearing on the motion, defendant Stillman did not take depositions, nor obtain opposing affidavits, nor conduct any other discovery.

The only ‘evidence’ submitted to the court opposing the motion for summary judgment was an affidavit by Stillman’s attorney which recited that on information and belief, plaintiff failed to perform certain obligations under the guarantee agreement.

The district court granted summary judgment in favor of plaintiff stating that defendant failed to submit appropriate affidavits opposing the motion as required by Minn.R.Civ.P. 56.06. Judgment was entered. There was no stay.

Within nine days after entry of summary judgment defendant fully paid the judg *52 ment and satisfaction of it was filed and the judgment discharged.

Ten weeks later defendant brought a motion under Minn.R.Civ.P. 60.02(1) to vacate judgment on grounds of excusable attorney neglect. Defendant claimed that before this time he did not have first hand knowledge, as required by Rule 56.05, of specific facts constituting defenses to their guarantee agreement. For this reason, he argues, he did not submit affidavits at the summary judgment motion hearing.

Another district judge of the Fourth Judicial District set aside the summary judgment, ruling the misunderstanding of Rule 56.05 constituted excusable neglect under Rule 60.02(1). The court order did not address the attorney’s failure to present affidavits, pursuant to Rule 56.05, of persons, other than defendant, who defendant knew had personal knowledge of the facts constituting a defense to the guarantee agreement, or the attorney’s failure to present affidavits pursuant to Rule 56.06 setting forth the reasons why a continuance was necessary. This appeal followed.

ISSUES

1. Does the district court lack subject matter jurisdiction to vacate a judgment which has been paid in full after entry of judgment?

2. Did the district court abuse its discretion in vacating summary judgment based on a claim of attorney neglect under Rule 60.02(1) where defendant’s attorney failed to present appropriate affidavits pursuant to Rule 56.05 in opposing summary judgment, and failed to submit an appropriate affidavit pursuant to Rule 56.06 stating reasons why a continuance was needed?

ANALYSIS

Issue No. 1

Bartel v. New Haven Tp., 323 N.W.2d 806 (Minn. 1982), held a voluntary payment of judgment during a stay of entry of the judgment extinguishes the right to appeal. Here, payment of judgment was made after the entry of judgment. However, Stillman did not ask for a stay of entry of the judgment; he did not appeal the summary judgment order, nor did he request a stay of execution of judgment. He voluntarily paid the judgment in full, satisfaction of judgment was filed, and the judgment discharged of record. All of this occurred some 10 weeks before the motion to vacate was filed.

Therefore, we hold that a judgment which is paid and satisfied of record ceases to have any existence leaving nothing to “vacate.”

Having determined that the trial court had no subject matter jurisdiction, only brief reference to the second issue will be made.

Issue No. 2

Minn.R.Civ.P. 56.05 (1959) provides:
When a motion for summary judgment is made and supported as provided in Rule 56, an adverse party may not rest upon the mere averments or denials of his pleading but must present specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial. If he does not so respond, summary judgment, if appropriate, shall be entered against him.

Summary judgment is appropriate where there are no material fact issues for trial and determination of the applicable law will resolve the controversy. Gaspord v. Washington County Planning Commission, 312 Minn. 591, 252 N.W.2d 590 (1977).

Here, there was no evidence properly submitted to the court pursuant to Minn.R.Civ.P. 56.05 opposing summary judgment. Nor was there an affidavit by the defendant stating reasons why a continuance was needed pursuant to Minn.R. Civ.P. 56.06.

The only evidence presented to the court at the time of the hearing of the motion for summary judgment was an affidavit by defendant’s attorney, stating that on information and belief, plaintiff failed to perform certain obligations under the lease guarantee agreement. Rule 56.05 requires *53 such affidavits to be made on personal knowledge. Thus, defendant’s attorney’s affidavit was not proper evidence, under Rule 56.05, to oppose summary judgment.

The evidence shows that long before the summary judgment motion was heard, defendant knew who had personal knowledge of facts which might support triable issues of fact, yet no effort was made to obtain their deposition testimony or affidavits. Summary judgment was properly entered by District Judge Robert E. Bowen.

To set aside a summary judgment, the moving party must meet four conditions. The party must (1) possess a reasonable defense on the merits, (2) have a reasonable excuse for the failure or neglect involved, (3) have acted with due diligence after notice of the entry of judgment, and (4) show that no substantial prejudice will result to the other party. Finden v. Klaas, 268 Minn. 268, 128 N.W.2d 748, 749 (1964) (emphasis added).

The. evidence establishes that plaintiff-appellant will be substantially prejudiced if vacation of judgment is allowed to stand. Since receiving the money from defendant, plaintiff has paid income taxes, estate taxes, and attorney’s fees for obtaining the judgment.

Apart from the question of subject matter jurisdiction, defendant has failed to meet all four Finden conditions.

The order to vacate summary judgment is reversed without prejudice to defendant’s third-party action.

SEDGWICK, J., took no part in the consideration or decision of this case.
This page includes AI-generated summaries and analysis based on the full opinion text and citing cases. We believe the summaries are accurate, but you should always verify the holdings, quotes, and treatment data against the original opinion before relying on them in legal proceedings.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.