Windom v. Wolverton
Can I rely on this case?
Yes — no negative treatment found
Analysis generated from citing opinions in this archive. Not legal advice.
Windom v. Wolverton
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiff, as the owner in fee-simple of certain tracts of vacant and .unoccupied land, brought this action, as authorized by Gen. St. 1878, c. 75, § 2, to determine an adverse claim made thereto by the defendant, who, by his answer, alleged title to the land in himself by and through certain tax proceedings and sales in the year 1875. He asserted no lien upon or other interest in the said lands. The court thereafter duly made and filed findings of fact, with a conclusion of law, upon which judgment was entered decreeing plaintiff to be the owner in fee-simple of said lands, and that the defendant had no estate, right, title, claim, interest, lien, incumbrance, or demand in or to any part thereof. Subsequently the court modified this judgment by striking out and eliminating therefrom the portion which adjudged and decreed that the defendant should have no lien upon the premises, and from such order plaintiff appeals.
The respondent’s position is that the judgment decree was too
The statute authorizing this method of procedure contemplates a determination of every adverse claim, estate, lien, or interest in a simple form of action. The office of the complaint herein was to bring to a determination all rights of every nature and kind asserted by the defendant, while in the answer is found the only interest he had or pretended to have in the property. .This interest was effectually disposed of by the findings, which would have sustained an. order for judgment commensurate with the judgment complained of as not justified. We are .of the opinion that all these matters may be considered in determining just what the trial court meant when stating in its conclusion of law that plaintiff was entitled to judgment “quieting title” in himself; and that, as plaintiff was, for the reasons mentioned, entitled to the relief actually awarded, there existed no ground for a modification of the judgment.
Order reversed.'
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William Windom v. W. D. Wolverton
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published