Boehl v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.
Can I rely on this case?
Citation treatment has not been reviewed for this case. The notes below come from the citation graph and the Minnesota Revisor's amendment records, not from a review of how later courts treated this decision.
(as of 9/30/2026)
Last cited by a Minnesota appellate court in 1925, among the opinions in this site’s citation index.
Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
See our Terms of Use before relying on these notes. Report an error
Cases that cite this one
20 later published cases cite this decision.
- Ruebel Bros. v. American Express Co. (Iowa 1920)
- Davis v. Sullivan Opry (Tex. Comm'n App. 1924)
- Alair v. Northern Pacific Railroad (Minn. 1893)
- Brower v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (Iowa 1934)
- S. G. Palmer Co. v. Illinois Central Railroad (Minn. 1925)
- Galveston, H. & S. A. Ry. Co. v. Neville (Tex. App. 1925)
- Bateham v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co. (Iowa 1923)
- Rustad v. Great Northern Railway Co. (Minn. 1913)
- Adams Express Co. v. Scott (Va. 1912)
- Cole v. Minneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Ste. Marie Railway Co. (Minn. 1912)
- Jordon v. Gulp & Ship Island Railroad (Miss. 1912)
- Willison v. Northern Pacific Railway Co. (Minn. 1910)
- Foust v. Lee (Mo. Ct. App. 1909)
- Ross v. Minneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Ste. Marie Railway Co. (Minn. 1907)
- Fockens v. United States Express Co. (Minn. 1906)
- Grant Smith v. Great Northern Railway Co. (Minn. 1904)
- Shea v. Minneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Ste. Marie Railway Co. (Minn. 1895)
- Abrams v. Milwaukee, Lake Shore & Western Railway Co. (Wis. 1894)
- Chaimson v. American Railway Express Co. (Wis. 1922)
- Swiney v. American Express Co. (Iowa 1908)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Carriers of live-stock are liable as common carriers for damages or injuries thereto arising during the transportation, except such as, without the fault or negligence of the carrier, result from the vitality of the freight; that is to say, the nature and propensity of animals to injure themselves or each other, their unruliness, restiveness, fright, viciousness, kicking, or goring, etc. The
In the ease at bar the plaintiff alleges the delivery by plaintiff to defendant, at Chicago, of a young stallion, about nine months old, to be transported- over its railway to Jackson, in this state, for hire; that the defendant undertook to do so, but so negligently conducted that it did not safely carry and deliver the animal as required by its contract; and the specific acts of negligence and misconduct are alleged and stated in the complaint to be the violent “bumping” of the cars; “that the defendant carelessly and negligently, and with great, sudden, and unnecessary force and violence, drove its engine and other ears against said car ‘in which said, stallion was being carried,” whereby the animal was with great force
And the only other question which it is necessary to consider is the alleged error of the court in its refusal to give to the jtífy the fourth instruction asked by the defendant, in which the court was requested to charge as follows: “The plaintiff cannot recover anything in this action unless, by a fair preponderance of evidence, he shall show that the stallion was killed by the negligence of the defendant company, its servants or agents, by reason of the bumping or jarring of cars at Brookfield, Wis.” It was not necessary that the complaint should specify the particular cause which produced the injury. As before mentioned, the plaintiff might have alleged generally the delivery of the chattel, and that it was injured while being transported, (Edw. Bailm. § 659;) and proof of these facts would have been sufficient to make a prima facie case of negligence on the part of the defendant, and the burden would then have rested on the defendant to show that the injury was not occasioned by its fault, mismanagement, or negligence. Still the onus oí proving to the satisfaction of the jury the essential facts alleged, and necessary to establish a prima facie case, would be upon the plaintiff, as in other cases. So in this case the burden was upon the plaintiff to establish by a preponderance of evidence that the animal was thrown down or injured by the violent collision of the cars as alleged, and this, unexplained, would make a prima facie case of negligence; and it would then devolve on the defendant, as a common carrier, controlling the agencies and instrumentalities through which the accident occurred, to disprove its negligence by showing that the injury was occasioned without its fault. The plaintiff was not bound to go further than to prove the facts necessary to establish a prima facie case. He was not obliged to prove affirmatively the misconduct or negligence of defendant’s agents which caused or resulted in the accident or produced the collision. A case having been made against the company, it was for it to excuse or explain it consistently with the faithful discharge of its duty. The rule is founded in reason and sound policy.
Order affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.