Belyea v. Minneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Sainte Marie Railway Co.
Can I rely on this case?
Citation treatment has not been reviewed for this case. The notes below come from the citation graph and the Minnesota Revisor's amendment records, not from a review of how later courts treated this decision.
(as of 9/30/2026)
Last cited by a Minnesota appellate court in 1977, among the opinions in this site’s citation index.
Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
See our Terms of Use before relying on these notes. Report an error
Cases that cite this one
10 later published cases cite this decision.
- Boland v. Morrill (Minn. 1967)
- Hudock v. Youngstown Municipal Ry. Co. (Ohio 1956)
- Eschenbach v. Benjamin (Minn. 1935)
- Fink v. Baer (Minn. 1930)
- Wells v. Minneapolis Baseball & Athletic Ass'n (Minn. 1913)
- City of Shawnee v. Sparks (Okla. 1910)
- Wells v. Moses (Minn. 1902)
- Busch v. Busch Construction, Inc. (Minn. 1977)
- Paulos v. Koelsch (Minn. 1935)
- Morris v. Grand Avenue Railway Co. (Mo. 1898)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This is an action for damages for personal injury to the plaintiff while a passenger on defendant’s railroad. On the trial the jury returned a verdict for plaintiff for the sum of $8,000, and from an order denying its motion for a new trial defendant appeals.
Plaintiff was not entitled to recover the expenses incurred for medical treatment, as these were expenses' for which her husband, was liable, and for which she was not liable. See Skoglund v. Minneapolis St. R. Co., 45 Minn. 330, 47 N. W. 1071. But whether the exceptions to the rulings of the court on this point are sufficient it is not necessary to decide, as the case must be reversed on another point.
At the close of the trial, and after the physicians in attendance had gone away, the plaintiff was recalled on her own behalf, and.
During the argument of plaintiff’s counsel to the jury, at the close of the evidence, the following proceedings took place: “Mr. Eeynolds said: We made an offer to prove what occurred at the residence of Mr. Belyea during the noon hour. This offer was objected to by defendant’s counsel, and excluded by the court. It is not a matter for your consideration; yet counsel for the defendant has referred to the offer, and made it the basis of an hour’s argument. We wish counsel had not objected. I wish this testimony could have been introduced. I wmuld have shown that the offer was not without foundation, as he claims, but that there was perpetrated the most villainous outrage. Mr. Bright: We object to the remarks of counsel relative to this offer. Court: Mr. Eeynolds, this offer is not in evidence, and you will not discuss it. Mr. Eeynolds: Counsel for defendant has referred to the offer. Court: You made no objection to it. Mr. Eeynolds: I wish 1 could have shown to this jury the infamous conduct of those two doctors. (To which statement Mr. Bright excepts.)” ,
This charge against these physicians was clearly prejudicial to 'the defendant, and may have had much to do with the rendition of ■so large a verdict. It sufficiently appears that the charge was not made in good faith. This appears not alone from the fact that Dr. Hunter never gave the testimony attributed to him, but also from ithe fact that counsel persisted in disregarding the rulings of the 'court, and reiterating the charge in his argument to the jury after Hie court had ruled that he must not discuss it.
For this misconduct of counsel, the order appealed from is reversed, and a new trial granted.
Buck, J., absent, took no part.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.