Vent v. Duluth Coffee & Spice Co.
Can I rely on this case?
Citation treatment has not been reviewed for this case. The notes below come from the citation graph and the Minnesota Revisor's amendment records, not from a review of how later courts treated this decision.
(as of 9/30/2026)
Last cited by a Minnesota appellate court in 1929, among the opinions in this site’s citation index.
Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
See our Terms of Use before relying on these notes. Report an error
Cases that cite this one
30 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Gasser v. Great Northern Insurance (Minn. 1920)
- Peir v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (9th Cir. 1938)
- Lyons v. Snider (Minn. 1917)
- Kom v. Cody Detective Agency, Inc. (Wash. 1913)
- Lyons v. Sachs (6th Cir. 1942)
- Learmouth v. Caledonia County Cooperative Creamery Assoc., Inc. (Vt. 1938)
- Downs v. Jersey Central Power, C., Co. (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1934)
- Coon v. Smith (District Court, E.D. Illinois 1933)
- Consolidated Music Co. v. Brinkerhoff Piano Co. (10th Cir. 1933)
- Pasotti v. United States Guardian Corp. (Court of Chancery of Delaware 1931)
- O'Brien Mercantile Co. v. Bay Lake Fruit Growers Ass'n (Minn. 1929)
- Booth v. Union Fibre Co. (Minn. 1919)
- Armstrong v. Union Trust & Savings Bank (9th Cir. 1918)
- Booth v. Union Fibre Co. (Minn. 1917)
- First National Bank v. Corporation Securities Co. (Minn. 1915)
- Schulte v. Boulevard Gardens Land Co. (Cal. 1913)
- Royal Glue Co. v. Lange (D.C. Cir. 1913)
- Adam v. New England Investment Co. (R.I. 1911)
- Allen v. Commercial Nat. Bank of Detroit (6th Cir. 1911)
- Mannington v. Hocking Valley Ry. Co. (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern Ohio 1910)
- Dickinson v. Zubiate Mining Co. (Cal. Ct. App. 1909)
- Porter v. Plymouth Gold Mining Co. (Mont. 1904)
- Vent v. Duluth Trust Co. (Minn. 1899)
- Ammon v. Cushman Motor Works (Neb. 1935)
- Oklahoma Natural Gas Corp. v. Douglas (Okla. 1934)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
On April 23, 1894, plaintiffs and the defendant corporation (then called the Smith & Coulter Spice Company) entered into the following agreement: “Parties of the first part [plaintiffs] agree to- take five thousand ($5,000) dollars’ worth of capital stock of the Smith & Coulter Spice Cods stock at par value, to be paid for on or before May 1st, ’94, which is to represent one-fourth interest in all assets of the company at this date. Parties of the second part [defendant] agree that on April 1st, 1895, if said parties of the first part are dissatisfied with the said stock or interest in said company, that the said Smith & Coulter Spice Go. will take stock from said parties of the first part, and pay them par value in cash for said stock, or interest in said company; parties of the first part to give notice by April 15th, 1895, and parties of the second part to have 60 days from said notice to pay for said stock.” Pursuant to this agreement, defendant issued the $5,000 of its stock to plaintiffs, who paid for the same in full. The name of the defendant has since been changed to the Duluth Coffee & Spice Company. On April 1, 1895, plaintiffs notified defendant that they were dissatisfied with the stock, offered to return the same, and demanded that they be paid the price of the same. On April 14 the demand was renewed, and the stock again offered to defendant. Defendant has not accepted the stock, or paid for the same, and, after the 60 days mentioned in the contract, this action was brought to recover the $5,000 so paid for the stock. On the trial the court ordered a verdict for plaintiffs for the amount claim
We are of tbe opinion tbat tbe evidence conclusively establishes all of tbe foregoing facts, and tbe only point raised by appellant worthy of consideration is tbe contention tbat the part of tbe contract by which defendant agreed to purchase or accept a surrender of its own stock is ultra vires and void. There is no express provision in its articles of incorporation authorizing defendant to buy or deal in its own stock, and whether an original, independent contract, by which it agreed to purchase its own stock, would be ultra vires, we need not consider. This is not such a case. This provision of the contract constituted a material and substantial part of the consideration and inducement for the purchase of the stock by plaintiffs, and, if the provision is void, it seems to us that it vitiates the whole contract, and is a sufficient reason for the rescission of that contract and the return of the purchase price, which purchase price plaintiffs are demanding. But the better opinion, it seems to us, is that which holds the original contract to be a conditional sale, with the option to revoke or rescind in the purchaser. In Browne v. St. Paul Plow Works, 62 Minn. 90, 64 N. W. 66, we held that a similar contract was not ultra vires. There is no question here as to the rights of creditors.
Order affirmed'.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.