State v. O'Brien

Minnesota Supreme Court
State v. O'Brien, 83 Minn. 6 (Minn. 1901)
85 N.W. 1135; 1901 Minn. LEXIS 608

Can I rely on this case?

Yes — no negative treatment found

Based on 7 citing opinions

Analysis generated from citing opinions in this archive. Not legal advice.

State v. O'Brien

Opinion of the Court

PER CURIAM.

Appeal from an order denying a motion to make tbe complaint more definite and certain. Plaintiff’s counsel claims tbe order is nonappealable and moves to dismiss. In American Book Co. v. Kingdom Pub. Co., 71 Minn. 363, 73 N. W. 1089, we expressly disapprove tbe rule laid down in Pugb v. Winona & St. P. R. Co., 29 Minn. 390, 13 N. W. 189, as to tbe appealability of sucb an order, and with a clear intimation that it would not be thereafter followed. We now expressly overrule tbe Pugb case, and bold that, as such an order relates to a matter of procedure and may be reviewed on an appeal from tbe judgment, if one is obtained against tbe defendants, it is not appealable under our statute. The appeal is dismissed, but without statutory costs.

Appeal dismissed.

Reference

Full Case Name
STATE v. PATRICK O'BRIEN and Others
Cited By
7 cases
Status
Published