Bradley v. Dinneen
Bradley v. Dinneen
Opinion of the Court
Action upon three promissory notes. Defendant answered admitting the execution of the notes, but alleged that the consideration therefor had failed, for the reason that the notes were given for the rental of a farm by lease to defendant, which plaintiff represented was in good condition for farming purposes, that the land thereon was broken and tillable, and that there was no foul seed, or anything which would in any manner impair the growth of crops thereon. It was further alleged in the answer that defendant was unacquainted with the land, and relied upon such representations, which were untrue; also that at the time of making the lease and executing the notes the untruthfulness of the representations was known to plaintiff, although defendant relied thereon, with allegations of damage, for which he asked an affirmative judgment by way of counterclaim. There was a denial by reply of the affirmative defensive matter thus pleaded. At the trial defendant attempted to establish the allegations of his answer by evidence tending to show the condition of crops raised on the farm, which was objected to as improper, irrelevant, and immaterial. This objection was sustained over defendant’s exception. Defendant then offered to prove that, at the time of the leasing of the land, defendant was unaware of its condition; also, that the farm contained foul seed, including wild mustard, and was so filled therewith as to render the same worthless and of no value. To this offer plaintiff objected, whereupon the court sustained the objection unless the defendant also proposed to prove representations made as to the character of the land of the nature pleaded in his answer, to which defendant excepted, and offered no evidence to sustain such representations, and rested, whereupon the court, at the request of the plaintiff, directed a verdict for the amount of the notes, which was entered. A motion for a new trial was made and denied. From this order defendant appealed.
The question involved on this appeal is within a very narrow compass. Defendant specifically alleged that certain representa
Order affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- J. C. BRADLEY v. DANIEL DINNEEN
- Status
- Published