B. J. Carney & Co. v. Bastian Electric Construction Co.
B. J. Carney & Co. v. Bastian Electric Construction Co.
Opinion of the Court
This action was brought in Wilkin county to foreclose a mechanic’s lien. The complaint was filed with the clerk of the district court of Wilkin county, August 19, 1922. It alleged the sale and delivery of the material for which a lien is claimed, on August 20, 1921. No other papers having been filed with the clerk, defendant Wolverton State Bank appeared specially in September, 1922, and moved to vacate the service of the summons. Accompanying the notice of
On this appeal the defendant contends that the summons was not served on this defendant within one year after the date of the last item of plaintiff’s claim, as required by G. S. 1913, § 7030. The sheriff’s return certified August 19, shows service on that day and within the year. The court was warranted in finding that service was made according to the sheriff’s return. Kueffner & Marks v. Gottfried, 154 Minn. 70, 191 N. W. 271.
’ Defendant contends that, since the summons was not filed until after the date of the trial court’s order, it cannot be considered as evidence of the date of service. As above stated, defendant demanded production of the original summons and return on the hearing, and these documents have been returned by the clerk to this court. We may assume that the summons and return were so produced, and in any event the record of the clerk’s office is now such that but one conclusion could well be reached as to the date of service.
The record is also decisive of service of the other necessary defendants within the year.
Order affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- B. J. CARNEY & COMPANY v. BASTIAN ELECTRIC CONSTRUCTION COMPANY AND OTHERS. WOLVERTON STATE BANK
- Status
- Published