Hanthorne v. Brooklyn Life Insurance
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is a suit in equity to enforce specific performance of a contract of life insurance. M. P. Hanthorne, one of the present plaintiffs, held a policy on his life, in the defendant, .on which policy he had paid several premiums. On this policy a semi-annual premium became due on December 28, 1871, and this premium not being paid at that date, several interviews took place between Hanthorne and the defendant’s agents; and it is upon what took place at these interviews that the present controversy chiefly turns. By this policy It was provided as follows: “After two annual payments, should the party wish to discontinue (notice to the company being given before the net premium becomes due), the company will issue a paid-up policy for as many tenths of the amount originally assured as there have been annual premiums paid in cash.” Under this clause, the plaintiffs contend that, more than the requisite number of premiums having been paid, they gave notice to the company and became entitled to a paid-up policy. This notice, they claim, was given orally to the defendant’s agent by Hanthorne, at one of the interviews above referred to, but the plaintiffs admit that it was not given until sometime in January, 1872, and, consequently, not until after December 28, 1871, when the premium became due. The defendant, on its part, contends "that, as this premium became due and remained unpaid, and as no notice was given of plaintiffs’ election to take a paid-up policy until January of the succeeding year, the plaintiffs failed to comply with the condition in the clause quoted, and are not entitled to a paid-up policy. In reply to this, the plaintiffs claim that by a previous course of
As the present is a bill in equity to enforce specific performance, and to secure the execution and delivery of a paid-up policy under the provision recited above, the question is not as to the forfeiture of the policy. The question is, Are the plaintiffs entitled to the relief they seek ? And this depends upon whether the plaintiffs have performed the conditions which, by the terms of their agreement, they were bound to perform before they could demand a paid-up policy. The rule that equity will not award specific performance unless it clearly appears that the terms of the agreement have been complied with, has its foundation in the best of reasons. Equity cannot make contracts, but can only compel their execution when made. By an express term of the policy, the defendant had a right to notice before the then next premium became due, and upon this condition precedent depended the plaintiffs’ right to a paid-up policy. This notice, before the maturity of the premium obligation, was not given, as the plaintiffs admit; how, then, can they obtain from a court of equity affirmative relief? Here was an obligation on its face requiring action on plaintiffs’ part. Without this action, presumptively, the minds of the parties could not have met; and, if the minds of the parties did not meet, — if, through a failure on the plaintiffs’ part, one term upon which, by the previous agreement, the defendant had insisted, was not complied with, — it is evident that to enforce performance would be to enforce a contract which the parties have not agreed upon. Thus the defendant may well complain — as it never got the prescribed notice, and the court must so find — that the court is making for it a contract which the defendant never made for itself.
The bill proceeds upon the theory of a complete perform
But, waiving this, and proceeding upon the ground that-they did give notice as claimed by them, the evidence is clearly insufficient to entitle the plaintiffs to specific performance. Let it be assumed that upon all previous occasions when semi-annual premiums were due, the defendant, permitted the pay-day to go by, and that there was what is called a course of dealing in this respect established. The inference cannot be drawn that because the defendant was willing to waive one condition it was willing to waive all. The
Apart from the fact that the evidence offered here as to waiver did not tend to prove waiver of the act here required to be done, it is evident that there is a difference in application between, the class of cases where waiver is relied on as an excuse for non-performance, with a view to averting a forfeiture of an executed contract, and cases like the present. The ground upon which the law proceeds in the first class of cases is explained in Thompson v. Insurance Company, 52 Mo. 469, and Hanley v. Life Association of America, 4 Mo. App. 253. The law does not favor forfeitures, and slight circumstances are allowed to go to the jury to show that the defendant waived per
The court below decreed performance in this case; but, for the reasons given, this was error, and, with the concurrence of all the judges, the decree is reversed and the bill dismissed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.