State ex rel. Zeppenfeld v. Wickham
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The petitioner seeks a mandamus to compel the respondent, as judge of the St. Louis Circuit Court, to sign a bill of exceptions tendered by the relator, in the case of Strohmaier v. Zeppenfeld, or else to permit the same to be filed, as provided by law, with the signatures of three by-standers. At the hearing, upon the return to the alternative writ, the relator rests his case upon a single proposition, which may he thus stated: That, under the tenth rule of practice adopted by the Circuit Court, the adverse party having failed to present, within three days after the relator’s bill of exceptions was'handed to him, his objections thereto, with the alterations and additions demanded, his objections, if any, were waived, and the judge was bound by law to .sign the bill of exceptions as tendered by the relator.
The relator seems to have fallen into the mistake of supposing that but two parties are to be consulted in the framing of a bill of exceptions ; that if the parties to the cause agree, or if one" party waives objections to a bill prepared
We have examined the so-called bill of exceptions which-the relator tendered for the respondent’s signature. It abounds in frivolous and meaningless objections, so framed? that, even if meritorious, they could not be noticed by an* appellate court. Otherwise, it is an unintelligible jumble-of words, which the respondent could not reasonably be expected to understand. We can imagine no state of facts in which it would be proper for a judge to sign, as a bill of" exceptions, such a paper as this.
On the other hand, the bill of exceptions which the-respondent signed presents numerous points saved by the relator at the trial, in a shape available for review on appeal or writ of error. Whether true and complete, or-otherwise, it certainly exhibits, in an intelligible form, the testimony and the rulings of the Circuit Court, and is,, therefore, far more favorable to the relator’s claims before-an appellate tribunal than the paper prepared by himself, which does nothing of the sort. Nothing is shown to us-concerning the alleged signing of a bill of exceptions by by-standers. The peremptory writ is refused.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.