Dean v. J. Kennard & Sons Carpet Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action for injuries to the person of Virginia Dean by the careless opening of a cellar door in the sidewalk of premises occupied by the defendant corporation.
After a general denial, defendant set up as a special de-fence that plaintiff Victoria Dean, in a former action in which her husband, George Dean, was joined as co-plaintiff, sued for damages for the same injury complained of in this' suit; that, when that action was reached for trial, plaintiff Victoria, in consideration of $250 then paid to her by defendant, signed an order of dismissal of that action, which was dismissed accordingly, and also, by a written instrument there and then signed by her, released all claim against defendant for the injury complained of. The writing is set out in full, and also filed as an exhibit with the answer, and is as follows: “Received, St. Louis, Mo., January 11, 1882, of J. Kennard & Sons Carpet Company, the sum of two hundred and fifty dollars, in full payment- and satisfaction of all claims, demands, damages, or causes of action against J. Kennai-d & Sons Carpet Company, growing out of any and all personal injuries to Victoria Dean or in favor of her and George Dean, her husband, caused to her by falling on a cellar door in April, 1881; and we do, in consideration of said payment, dismiss the suit now pending, and release and discharge said J. Kennard &
The reply of plaintiffs admits the institution of the suit for the same cause of action, and that plaintiff Victoria signed the exhibit and the memorandum dismissing the suit, and that the same was dismissed ; they say that the exhibit was never delivered by them, and was signed by Victoria Dean under the belief that her husband, who was not present, would consent, and had authorized the settlement, and would sign the exhibit, which was not to be delivered without his consent, which she believed to be essential to give effect to the paper; and that, when she discovered her mistake, she caused her name to be erased from the exhibit ; that said exhibit was not to be effective without the consent of George Dean, and was retained by the attorney of plaintiff to get his signature; that George Dean refused to sign, and erased her signature, and that the exhibit came into defendant’s possession after her name was erased, and after George Dean had written his dissent upon its face. Plaintiffs deny the payment of receipt' of any money by way of a compromise or settlement, but admit that defendant gave its check to plaintiffs’ attorney for $250, which check plaintiffs have never received, and which they directed their attorneys to return to defendants. The reply denies the execution or delivery of the contract set up in the answer, and all allegations as to a compromise or settlement.
At the close of the case the court instructed the jury, that upon the pleadings and evidence plaintiffs were not entitled to recover. Plaintiffs then took a non-suit, which the trial court refused to set aside.
There is no conflict of testimony as to the special defence set up in the answer. It appears from the evidence that a former suit had been commenced by Mrs. Dean against the defendant, for the same cause of action set up in the petition
Mrs. Dean was the real and only person in interest in the action for damages growing out of a violation of her personal rights. Rev. Stats., sect. 3296. Her husband was made a co-plaintiff because the practice act requires it; but she was sui juris as to the matter by statute, and quite competent to compromise the matter and direct the dismissal of the suit without consulting her husband. Alt v. Meyer, 8 Mo. App. 198; Hooton v. Ransom, 6 Mo. App. 19. Her husband’s assent or dissent is absolutely immaterial.
The common law merged the personality of the wife in that of her husband ; the civil law does- not. The tendency of legislation, in countries in which the common law prevails, is to do away with the old rules of the common law in this respect. Opinions may be divided as to the wisdom or expediency of these changes. With this we are not concerned. Whilst the law is in this state of transition some anomalies will exist. The legislature, in passing an enactment effecting the status or property rights of married women, does not always look through the statute book to
The judgment is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.