Mann v. City of Rich Hill
Opinion of the Court
This is an action by plaintiff to recover damages for loss of service and companionship, as well as for the expenses incurred, resulting from an injury to his wife on one of defendant’s sidewalks. The principal portion of the petition is as follows : “That, between Seventh and Eighth streets aforesaid, between lots 7 and 8, in block 54, of said city, upon the north side of Park avenue aforesaid, the defendant, on the second day of December, 1885, and for a long time prior thereto, unmindful of its duty to the public aforesaid, wrongfully, carelessly, and negligently permitted said sidewalk to become and remain out of repair, in such a manner as to become unsafe and dangerous to foot-travelers using said street; that, at the place and at the time last aforesaid, a plank or board on said sidewalk was loose, broken, and too short, by reason of which said sidewalk was dangerous and unsafe for foot-travelers thereon ; that, on or about December 2, 1885, the said Sarah Mann, wife of plaintiff, while traveling along said sidewalk at the place where said plank or board was loose, broken, etc., as aforesaid, without any knowledge upon her part of its loose, broken, unsafe, and dangerous condition aforesaid, and without fault upon her part, while walking along and upon said sidewalk, stepped upon said loose board or plank herself, or the same was stepped upon by one of her companions, by reason of which it became misplaced, threw down and injured the said Sarah Mann, the wife of plaintiff, bruised, wounded, and injured her in her left knee, upon the left side of
The evidence for plaintiff tended to support the allegations of the petition, and, if believed by the jury, tended to make out an injury of an aggravated and permanent character. There was a verdict for plaintiff for fifteen hundred dollars, and defendant appeals. Several instructions were given for either party; three of those given for plaintiff were all that were excepted to by defendant. All asked were given for defendant but three, and to the refusal of these, exceptions were taken.
It appears that plaintiff’s wife had, before this trial, instituted suit against defendant for the same injury, being joined nominally therein by plaintiff, in which action she recovered judgment against defendant. That action was no bar to this, but defendant contends that all matters complained of and for which judgment is asked in this case, were actually litigated and adjudicated in that case. And for the purpose of proving this, defendant offered in evidence the record of that case, including the petition, answer, and instructions. The court excluded it. Passing by the question whether this case is to be affected, though improper matter was adjudicated in the
The instructions ref used for defendant were properly refused. The court would not have been justified in instructing the jury that there was no evidence of the accident causing a fracture of the "ilium or pelvic bone.” There was evidence showing such fracture and that it did not exist before the accident. Though such fracture was possibly not discovered by the physician who attended her at the time of the accident, yet there was evidence showing it might have existed and not been discovered for reasons stated by the witnesses. Instruction number nine was covered by instructions which were given.
The objection, that evidence was admitted of injuries not covered by the petition, was not well taken. There was no motion asking that the petition be made more specific.
We have given careful consideration to the comprehensive brief submitted by defendant, but are of the opinion that, under the legal rules and principles applicable to this case, we cannot interfere with the judgment, and it is, therefore, with the concurrence of the other judges, affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.