Kuttner v. Lindell Railway Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This was an action for damages for personal injuries claimed to have been produced by the concurring negligence of the two defendants. The petition charges in substance that the defendants are corporations engaged in the business of common carriers of persons for hire, by means of horse-cars, upon certain streets of the city of St. Louis ; that, on the twenty-ninth day of December, 1886, the said Lindell Railway Company received plaintiff upon one of its cars as a passenger, and that he paid the fare required of passengers; that, while a passenger on said car, the car in which he was riding, at the intersection of Yandeventer avenue and Morgan street, collided with the grip-car of the defendant, the
The answer of the St. Louis Cable & Western Railway Company is a general denial. The answer of the Lindell Railway Company is: (1) A general denial; (2) contributory negligence by the plaintiff; (3) that the plaintiff’s injuries were brought about through the fault and neglect of its co-defendant, and without fault or neglect on its part.
The evidence at the trial tended to show that the defendant, the Lindell Railway Company, operates a line of street cars in the city of St. Louis, drawn by horses; and that the defendant, the St. Louis Cable & Western Railway Company, operates a line of street cars in St. Louis, the motor power of which is an underground cable, propelled by a stationary engine, to which cable its cars are attached, and from it detached, by means of a grip, operated by an employe called a “gripman”, by means of a lever; that the accident took place after dark, in the evening ; that the plaintiff had taken passage upon a car of the defendant, the Lindell Railway Company, which car was of the familiar pattern known as a “bobtail”, drawn by two horses in charge of a driver; that the railway of the Lindell Company runs north and south on Yandeventer avenue, and that the railway of the Cable Company runs east and west on Morgan street, so that the tracks of the two companies cross each other' at right angles at the intersection of Morgan street and Yandeventer avenue ; that the conformation of the ground and the location of adjacent buildings is such that when a car of the Lindell Company, going north, reaches a point within sixty feet of the south track of the Cable Company which is used by its east-bound cars, the driver of the car of the Lindell Company can see to the west along the track of the Cable
The court refused to withdraw the case from the-jury, but submitted it to them on a very full series of instructions, in which we see nothing of which either appellant can complain.
I. It is obvious that there was evidence of negligence sufficient to take the question to the jury, as against both the defendants. It is almost demonstrably clear that, where the drivers of two street railway cars approach an intersection of their tracks, and each has the means of seeing the approach of the other in time to-stop his own vehicle before arriving at the intersection, and has control of his own vehicle so as to be able to stop it, if a collision occurs, there is evidence of negligence in both drivers ; since the drivers of the two-vehicles are under an equal duty of avoiding the collision, and if either stops his vehicle before arriving at the intersection, there can be no collision. We have not referred to the evidence of other witnesses than the two drivers. If the evidence of either driver is true, the other driver was guilty of negligence; and we incline to think that, considering the established physical surroundings, the testimony of each driver — that
II. The Cable Company relies upon the doctrine of Thorogood v. Bryan, 8 Com. Bench. 115, by which the negligence of the driver of the lindell car would be imputed to the plaintiff, because of his misfortune of being a passenger on that car, so as to bar his recovery of damages against the Cable Company. The doctrine of that case is thoroughly repudiated both in England and America. It was lately denied by the Supreme Court of the United,States (Little v. Hackett, 116 U. S. 366), and overruled by the English Court of Appeal. The Bennina, 56 Law Times (N. S.)158.
The rule there announced was contrary to the plainest conceptions of justice, and was founded in mere casuistry, and we have no disposition to attempt to revive it.
The judgment of the circuit court will be affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.