Fulton v. Phoenix Insurance
Opinion of the Court
On November 15, 1887, the defendant issued its policy of insurance on a farm dwelling and contents belonging to plaintiff Fulton, loss if any payable to the trustee of the Phoenix Mutual Life Insurance Company as its interest as mortgagee might appear. On September 11, 1891, and during the life of the policy, the building and contents were destroyed by fire. Defendant failing to pay the insurance, this action was brought, resulting in a verdict and judgment for plaintiffs, and defendant appealed.
I. The defense relied upon was the failure to make proof of loss within thirty days provided in the policy. That such proofs were not made within the time stipulated in the policy was admitted, but plaintiffs relied on a waiver thereof by defendant. Now the petition declared plaintiffs’ compliance with all the requirements and conditions of the policy; but at the
There was, too, in this case abundant evidence to justify the court in submitting the question of waiver to the jury. Immediately after the fire, plaintiff Fulton (who lived it seems about twenty miles from the agency that issued the policy) wrote a letter addressed to the former agent, Stephens, who had written the policy, informing him of the fire, and asking for instructions as to how he, Fulton, should proceed, etc. Stephens forthwith turned over Fulton’s letter to Spencer, his successor, at Linneus. Spencer thereupon wrote to Burch, the general agent at Chicago, informing him of the particulars of the loss. This general agent replied to Spencer promising to have the adjuster come upon the ground, and settle the loss. Whereupon Spencer, the local agent, under date of September 19 (only eight days after the fire), wrote the following to plaintiff Fulton:
“D. W. Fulton, Esq., Neio Boston, Mo.:
“Deas Sib: — Mr. Ceo. W. Stephens, Sr., of this place reported your loss under policy number 1184. This day I received a letter from the company stating their Mr. Hamlin would call and settle with you.
‘ ‘Eespectfully yours,
“E. H. Spencek.”
It seems that after the expiration of the thirty days, within which the proof of loss was required by the terms of the policy, defendant refusing to settle the loss, plaintiff Pulton did make out and left with defendant a formal proof of loss. To the introduction of this proof in evidence defendant objected, and now insists that it was error to admit said paper. I am inclined to regard this as error, in that the paper was wholly useless. Making proof sixty days after the loss did not show
"We have read and considered the instructions given, and we regard them as a fair presentation of the law of the case. The judgment is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.