State v. Weese
State v. Weese
Opinion of the Court
The defendant was indicted for obstructing “a certain public road running between sections 5 and 8, in township number 66, of range number 32 (Worth county, state of Missouri), and known as the A1 Black road, by fencing and building a fence of
The point mainly relied on for reversal is an alleged variance between the allegation of the indictment and the evidence as to the place where the road was obstructed. Defendant’s farm consists of one hundred and twenty acres, eighty of which are described as the south half of the southwest quarter of section 5, and forty acres immediately south of said eighty, and described as the northwest quarter of the northwest quarter of section 8, all in township 66, range 32. The public road in question runs east and west between this eighty in section 5, and the forty in section 8; in other words, the road runs along the north line of the northwest quarter of section 8, and which is also the south line of the southwest quarter of section 5. And it was this portion of the public road — running between said sections 5 and 8 — which the defendant, as the evidence shows, obstructed by erecting across the same a wire fence and gates.
The indictment, now, in so far as it describes the road obstructed as “a certain public road running between sections 5 and 8, township 66, in range 32, and known as the A1 Black road,” is clear and sufficient, ' and fully corresponds with the evidence; but because this description is followed by the contradictory words, “ where said road runs along the south side of the southwest quarter of section 8,” it is said to locate the locus in quo a half mile south of road shown in evidence, and produce such a variance between the allegata and probata as to prove fatal to the prosecution.
We think these repugnant words, added to the
Other objections have been examined, and as we find no merit in any of them the judgment will be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.