Glaves v. Morrow
Opinion of the Court
As the errors complained of are based upon the state of the pleadings in this case, we set them out in full. The petition is as follows:
‘ ‘Plaintiff; states that on the-day of February, 1894, one Elias Morrow, then a resident of said county, departed this life intestate, and that on the first day of June, 1894, this plaintiff under the order and direction of the probate court took charge of his estate and filed*384 a written notice thereof in the office of the judge of the probate court of said county.
“Plaintiff further states, that'at the time of the death of said Elias Morrow, the defendant was indebted to the said Elias Morrow in the sum of five hundred dollars for money loaned by said Elias in his lifetime to said defendant, to wit, in the year 1891.
“Plaintiff states that no part of said sum has been paid by defendant but is still due and unpaid, and is now due and owing to this plaintiff. Plaintiff states that on or about the first day of August, 1894, he demanded payment of the defendant of the said sum of money which he refused to make. Wherefore plaintiff prays judgment for the said sum of five hundred dollars, with interest from the first day of August, 1894.”
To which petition respondent answered as follows:
“Now at this day (leave of court first being had) comes the defendant and files his answer herein. Admits that the plaintiff is public administrator of Lewis county, Missouri, and has in charge the estate of Elias Morrow, deceased. Admits that Elias -Morrow departed this life intestate; but denies that he, the defendant, was indebted to said Elias Morrow, deceased, in the sum of five hundred dollars for money loaned by said Elias Morrow in his lifetime to this defendant in the year 1891.
“Defendant for further answer to plaintiff’s petition states that the said Elias Morrow was in poor health, was an old man for a long time previous to his death; that all of his family had grownup and left him and that he was unable to work and look after his farm and that this defendant is his son, and that he, at the request and solicitation of his father, said Elias Morrow, deceased, went to live on a small portion of said Morrow’s farm, and occupied a small house and*385 six or seven acres of land on said farm at the time he moved on said land; that this defendant lived on said land for about twelve or fifteen years, and during all that time he worked for the said Elias Morrow on his farm, doing all kinds of farm work, assisted him in getting his wood, harvesting and taking care of his crops and improving said farm, and taking care^f his stock. Defendant says that after he had lived as aforesaid on the land aforesaid of his said father, Elias Morrow, deceased, he purchased a small farm, and that his father, said Elias Morrow, at the time he purchased the small farm, paid him the sum of five hundred dollars, which was all the compensation he ever received from his said father for all the work done by this defendant for all the years he worked for his said father as aforesaid. Wherefore defendant says he owes plaintiff nothing and asks to be discharged with his costs.
“Benjamin J. Morrow.
“By G-eo. Ellison and B. E. Thompson, Att’ys.”
To this answer appellant filed the following replication :
“Now at this day comes the plaintiff, and for replication to defendant’s answer denies each and every allegation therein contained or any knowdedge or information thereof sufficient to form a belief.
“Blair & Marchand and John C. Anderson,
“Att’ys for plaintiff.”
The respondent is the son of the intestate Elias Morrow. The appellant as a witness for himself, testified substantially that he presented a note of $500 to the respondent, to be signed on account of money he had borrowed from the deceased; that the respondent said he had received the money from his father and would sign the note if the other heirs would give their notes for what they justly owed the estate. Other witnesses testified to admissions of a similar character
The evidence showed that Elias Morrow, the deceased, was an old man, living on a farm, and that all of his children had left him, excepting Ben, who had lived on a part of this farm for twelve or fourteen years after he became of age, and after he had a family of his own. There was no evidence as to any contract between Ben and his father, and no account of the $5.00 found among the papers and books of the deceased so far as is shown by the record.
“The plaintiff sues for five hundred dollars which he alleges the defendant borrowed of Elias Morrow, deceased. If the evidence shows that defendant borrowed of Elias Morrow deceased, $500 or more in his lifetime, then in such case, the jury will find for plaintiff for the sum of $500 with interest from January 31, 1895.”
And the following instructions on the part of the respondent:
“(1) The burden of proving his case rests upon the plaintiff and before plaintiff can recover he must prove by a fair preponderance of evidence that defendant was indebted to Elias Morrow, deceased, at the time of his death.”
“(2) Plaintiff can not recover for money given by Elias Morrow, deceased, to defendant to buy land if such gift is shown.”
To the giving of respondent’s instructions (numbers 1 and 2) appellant duly objected and excepted at the time. The jury returned a verdict for respondent. After an unsuccessful motion for a new trial, appellant brings his case here by appeal.
Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
Dissenting Opinion
(dissenting). — I have been unable to concur in the majority opinion in this case. Discarding irrelevant matter the answer is a special denial. It admits the receipt of the money as charged, but denies that it was received as a loan, thus presenting the single issue of loan or no loan. The other matters stated in the answer are argumentative, and do not constitute new matter upon which an issue could be taken. “An argumentative denial arises when the pleader mistakes the matter which may be used as evidence to support a denial, and pleads as though it were new matter.” (1 Enc. of Pleading and Practice, p. 799). In other words, it is pleading evidence, which should be stricken out on motion or treated as surplusage. Thus it has been held that when the action is ex contractu, an answer setting up a different contract to that stated in the petition is an argumentative
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.