Rives v. City of Columbia
Rives v. City of Columbia
Opinion of the Court
This is an action by the plaintiff against the city of Columbia and certain of its officers, who are codefendants, to recover damages alleged to have been occasioned by the making of certain street improvements. The question which the appeal brings before us is one relating to the taxation of cost in the court below.
It appears that after the issues in the case had been made up by the pleadings the plaintiff, in conformity to the requirements of section 6089, Revised Statutes, applied for, and obtained an order of the court for a special jury. It further appears that after the special jury so ordered had been impaneled and the challenges made the plaintiff, at that point, took a voluntary nonsuit and judgment was given accordingly. There was however a clause in the judgment to the effect that, “the cost of summoning said special venire and the attendance (per diem and mileage) of the same amounting to twenty dollars and ninety cents be and the .same is hereby taxed against defendants,” etc. It is contended by the defendants that the action of the court in taxing the cost of said special jury against them was unauthorized by the statute and therefore erroneous.
Nor is there anything in said section 6089 to justify the taxation of the cost of said special jury against the defendants. It provides, “that the cost of such special jury shall be paid by the party appkjmg, irrespective of the result, unless the judge * *• * certify that the case was one for the trial of which a special jury should have been ordered, in which case the costs of the special jury shall be taxed as other costs against the losing party.” It is clear from this that the party who applies for and obtains the order for the sj>ecial jury shall pay the cost thereof, irrespective of the result in the case, no difference what may happen, unless the trial judge at the close of the case shall certify that it was one for the trial of which a special jury should have been ordered. The only qualification of the liability of the party applying for the special jury to pay the costs thereof is that just stated.
The judgment must be reversed and cause remanded with directions to enter judgment for the defendants for the item of $20.90, the same being the amount of the cost of the special jury.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.