Missouri Court of Appeals, 1899

Marre v. GridLet

Marre v. GridLet
Missouri Court of Appeals · Decided November 14, 1899 · Biggs, Bland, Bond
81 Mo. App. 470

Marre v. GridLet

Opinion of the Court

BLAND, J.

Section 2301, Revised Statues 1889 requires the appellant to “make out and furnish the court with a clear and concise statement of the case.” * * * Rule 15 of this court requires that this statement shall be filed at least one day before the cause is called for trial, and Rule 19 provides that for failure to comply with Rule 15, the appeal shall be dismissed or the cause reset on terms. The appellant *471has failed to comply with the statute and Rule 15. His attention has been called to this neglect by the statement and brief, of respondent; without any effort to repair his negligence he has submitted the case. The statute and rule are not meaningless and must be observed and complied with in this court, if appellants wish the opinion of the court on the merits of their cases.

Eor failure to comply with the statute and rule the appeal is dismissed.

Judge Bond concurs; Judge Biggs dissents.

Dissenting Opinion

DISSENTING OPINION BY

JUDGE BIGGS.

I am of the opinion that the original and reply briefs of the appellant contain a sufficient statement of the record to require us to dispose of the case on its merits, this court has not heretofore strictly enforced the letter of the statute.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.