Bertig-Smythe v. Bonsack Lumber Co.
Opinion of the Court
(after stating the facts). — Is the order sued on ambiguous? If so, the ambiguity arises out of the closing clause or sentence of the order, to-wit: “With all overplus on lumber when shipped.” The term with “denotes or expresses some situation or relation of nearness, proximity, association, connection, or the like. It is used to denote the accompaniment of cause, means, instrument, etc.; sometimes equivalent to by.” [Webster’s Dictionary.]
The order may be construed-to mean the three hundred dollars was to be paid to plaintiff unconditionally, plus any overplus on lumber to be thereafter shipped or, with equal fidelity to- the language employed, it may be construed to mean that the three hundred dollars was to be paid from or out of any overplus on lumber to be thereafter shipped. Its susceptibility to this double construction makes it ambiguous or obscure and for this reason a resort to parol testimony was necessary to show
The judgment is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.