Hoffman v. St. Louis Refrigerator & Cold Storage Co.
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Rollins v. Schawacker (Mo. Ct. App. 1910)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This action was to recover the amount of $400 alleged to be due plaintiffs by the following contract :
“St. Louis, Mo., May 30, 1905.
“Fred Hoffman & Co.,
“301 Benoist,
St. Louis, Mo.
“Gentlemen: We have this day made the following contract with your Mr. Hogan. In consideration of the-payment to you of $400, you contract and agree so to contruct the sewer you are about to build in the alley between Pine and Olive and Twelfth and Thirteenth streets, running north, that it will not affect or cause to settle our conduit that at present is located in the alley, according to the tracing we have this day given to your Mr. Hogan; and you further agree that if, in constructing this sewer, you' do cause us any damage, that you will pay all losses to which we are put by reason of the damage.
“The $400 is to be paid to you when you have finished the sewer and the same has been accepted by the city of St. Louis.
“It is understood that your acceptance of this contract is on the condition that the board of public improvements shall stake out the sewer west of our conduit.
“If you are prepared to confirm this contract please sign and return to us one copy of this letter, which is issued in duplicate, you retaining the other.
“Yours truly,
“St. Louis Eefrigerator & Cold Storage Co.,
“Accepted: “T. S. McPheeters, President.
“Fred H. Hoffman & Co.,
“T. F. Hogan.”
The action was originally instituted before a justice of the peace and a statement filed which, after declaring on the instrument just copied, averred that plaintiffs constructed and finishel the sewer between Pine and
Plaintiffs were under contract with the city of' St. Louis to lay a large sewer pipe in an alley. The defendant had three conduits or pipes laid in the alley about three feet below the surface. One of those pipes was filled with ammonia, one with ammonia gas and the other was a vacuum to be used if either of the others got out of order. The pipes were employed in connection with the system of refrigeration furnished to various business establishments in the city; among others the Jefferson Hotel. Defendant’s pipes carried a pressure of one hundred and twenty-five to one hundred and eighty-five pounds, and the testimony goes to show that if they sagged it would be easy for the ammonia or ammonia gas to escape. The sewer was to be constructed seventeen feet below the surface of the alley and fourteen feet below defendant’s pipes. The tes
“Whenever underground pipes or conduits, either public or private, are encountered during the progress of the work, the contractor shall sustain them by timber and chains, or otherwise, so as to keep them in position and free from injury. Any damage to underground pipes, or conduits, resulting from any work done under this contract, from any neglect or carelessness of the contractor, may be repaired by the proper party, and the costs thereof shall be paid by the contractor on demand, and in default of payment may be recovered by said party in any court of competent jurisdiction, of the contractor and his securities, or any one of them hereunder; or if the claim is for work done by the city of*666 St. Louis, no certificate of the completion of the work done under this contract shall be given by the sewer commissioner until payment is made.”
There were other clauses in the city’s contract providing in substance, that plaintiffs should be governed by the orders of the city sewer commissioner, who should have the right to determine the amount, quantity and. classification of the several kinds of materials to be paid for under the agreement with the city, and to decide all questions in relation to the agreement; that plaintiffs should give a bond with the National Security Company, as surety, in the sum of more than six thousand dollars, conditioned that, in the event plaintiffs faithfully performed their work according to contract with the city and paid all proper parties for materials and labor used, the obligation should be void; otherwise should remain in full force and to be sued on in the name of the city at the instance of any materialman, laborer or mechanic who was injured by a breach of its conditions. The theory on which the verdict was ordered for defendant was, that the contract between plaintiffs and defendant bound the former to do no more than they were reasonably bound to do under their contract with the city and, hence, there was no consideration for defendant’s agreement to pay $400 if the work of laying the sewer was performed so as not to affect defendant’s conduits or cause them to settle.
Further reference needs to be made to the testimony regarding the execution of the contract in suit. One of the plaintiffs testified that when they went to excavating for the sewer, they found defendant’s pipes in the center of the’.street instead of at the side as they expected and as the plat of the pipes filed with the city showed; that the pipes were full of ammonia and ammonia gas and plaintiffs requested defendant to abandon the use of them temporarily until the sewer was laid, because, if a conduit was broken, the gas would endanger the lives of the men digging in the sewer ditch; that
Judgment having been entered for defendant, plaintiffs appealed.
The position taken by defendant’s counsel is that the contract in suit is unsupported by a consideration because it imposed no greater responsibility on plaintiffs than they were under already by virtue of their contract with the city of St. Louis. We refrain from passing on the question of whether a promise to do what the promissor is already under a legal obligation to do by virtue of a prior contract between him and a third party, is a good consideration for an undertaking by the promisee to compensate him for doing the thing agreed — whether or not under those circumstances, an action will lie on the promisee’s obligation. This is a question on which the authorities are in conflict. In our judgment it is not true in the case at bar that plaintiffs assumed no greater responsibility and duty to defendant regarding its pipes, than they had assumed in the contract with the city; and by every authority we have found, if the agreement in suit was more detrimental to plaintiffs than the agreement with the city was, or put them under a broader obligation, there was a consideration for defendant’s undertaking to compensate them. [Pollock,
The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.