Shoush v. Missouri Pacific Railway Co.
Shoush v. Missouri Pacific Railway Co.
Opinion of the Court
This is a suit by plaintiff to recover damages for an injury she sustained by reason of the alleged negligence of defendant. The facts, as they appear from plaintiff’s evidence, and which are. practically undisputed by any evidence on the part of defendant, are that on the twenty-second day of August, 1904, after having procured a ticket for transportation over defendant’s road from Holden to Higgin'sville by way of Kansas City, Missouri, she attempted to board* one of defendant’s trains at its station in Holden; and that after she had got upon the first step and before she got to the platform the-car suddenly started which had the effect of throwing her down, and she was severely injured.
It was shown that defendant’s train stops at said station from three to four minutes to let off and take on passengers; that plaintiff was on the platform of the station at a proper place ready to board the train; that
The defendant’s contention is that under the evidence plaintiff was not entitled to recover. Defendant’s grounds for this contention have no foundation whatever. It is not predicated upon, plaintiff’s evidence and there is, as said, no substantial evidence upon the part of defendant to overcome that of plaintiff.
There is a special objection made to instruction number one given for plaintiff, viz.: that it submits an issue not made by the pleadings. Said instruction is as follows: “The court instructs the jury that it was the duty of defendant as a common carrier of passengers, by its agents and employees, to have stopped its passenger cars at the depot platform at Holden, Missouri, a sufficient length of time to have made it safe for ingress and egress of passengers in and from the same, and to
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.