Kellog-Mackey-Cameron Co. v. Curtice
Opinion of the Court
Replevin. This suit was commenced in a justice court where it was tried and judgment had from which appeal was taken to the circuit court. The plaintiff claims. to be entitled to the possession of sixteen radiators of the value of $133.83 in the possession of and detained by defendant.
The facts are that sometime in the fall of 19091, the defendant, Curtice', entered into a contract with Rood & McIntyre, a co-partnership engaged in the busi
On January 17, 1910, Rood & McIntyre filed their petition in bankruptcy at which time plaintiff first learned of their insolvency. There was evidence that Curtice had made some payment to said co-partnership on the said contract, but the radiators were not installed in his building. The plaintiff recovered judgment which the court set aside upon motion of defendant for a new trial. Prom the action of the court in setting aside the judgment plaintiff appealed.
The action of the court must be upheld for the reason that under the facts plaintiff w^as not entitled to recover because it was'not entitled to the possession of the property in controversy. The sale to Rood & McIntyre was unconditional and passed to them the title to the property. Because the co-partnership went into bankruptcy did not affect the right of property in the radiators so far as plaintiff was concerned. At the time the suit was begun the trustee in bankruptcy had not asserted his right to the property, but he may do so at any time as the title to the same is in the bankrupt co-partnership. And the fact that plaintiff
Appellant contends that it had the right to rescind the contract of sale of the materials. We know of' no law to that effect. Plaintiff has no grounds for rescission of the contract except that the purchasers failed to pay for the goods. Plaintiff having failed to show any right to the possession of the goods the cause is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.