Missouri Court of Appeals, 1912

Granite Bituminous Paving Co. v. Parkview Realty & Improvement Co.

Granite Bituminous Paving Co. v. Parkview Realty & Improvement Co.
Missouri Court of Appeals · Decided December 3, 1912 · Nortoni, Rombauer
168 Mo. App. 494; 151 S.W. 487; 1912 Mo. App. LEXIS 441

Granite Bituminous Paving Co. v. Parkview Realty & Improvement Co.

Dissenting Opinion

*495DISSENTING OPINION.

070rehearing

ON MOTION FOR REHEARING.

R. E. ROMBAUER, Special Judge.

The record in this cause is identical with, the one in 12,563, except the amount sued for and the property sought to be charged with the lien of the special taxbill.

It is therefore ordered that the motion for rehearing be sustained, that the record entry of the judgment be amended, as is ordered to be done in cause 12,563, and as thus amended be affirmed, and that the cause be remanded to the trial court for further proceedings. In this disposition of the case Reynolds, P. J., concurs. Caulfield, J., not sitting. Nortoni, J., dissents for the reason stated in his dissenting opinion in cause No. 12,563. The cause is therefore certified to the Supreme Court for final determination.

Opinion of the Court

NORTONI, J.

As the judgment of the court in this case involves the identical question and determines it in the same way as that involved in the case of Granite Bituminous Paving Company v. Parkview Realty & Improvement Company et al., (No. 12,563), between the same parties and decided today (168 Mo. App. 468, 151 S. W. 479), I respectfully dissent therefrom for the reasons given in the dissenting opinion filed in the case last mentioned. I deem the judgment of the court in this case to be in conflict with the judgment of the Kansas City Court of Appeals in the case of Forrey v. Holmes, 65 Mo. App'. 114 and also with the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Morey Engineering & Construction Co. v. St. Louis Artificial Ice Rink Co., 242 Mo. 241, 146 S. W. 1142. and therefore request that the cause be certified to the .Supreme Court for final determination, as provided in the Constitution.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.