Snyder v. Patrick
Snyder v. Patrick
Opinion of the Court
This action was begun in tbe probate court of Cass county on a claim against tbe estate of Grant Fulton, deceased. On appeal to the-circuit court a demurrer to the evidence was offered by tbe executor and sustained by tbe court.
Tbe demurrer was sustained on tbe ground of incompetency of witnesses testifying for plaintiff. These were herself and ber son Fred Snyder. It appeared tbe deceased was plaintiff’s uncle, ber mother being deceased’s sister. Their father died and this plaintiff, bis granddaughter, became tbe owner of forty acres of bis landed estate. But ber husband being an improvident man of uncertain habits, she bad tbe title put in tbe name of ber minor son Fred, so as to make certain tbe husband would not get it from ber. It further appears that deceased- bad charge of bis father’s business and managed and controlled bis lands and that be continued this management and control over tbe forty which came to plaintiff. That be collected tbe rents and profits for several years without accounting' to plaintiff or ber son. Finally be sold tbe
The statement which we have made is sufficiently full to make clear our conclusions. To justify the demurrer, Fred must have been an incompetent witness ;■ for if he is to be believed plaintiff is entitled to recover. His competency is insisted upon on the ground' that he was deceased’s agent and whether he was or not must be determined from his testimony in deciding whether the demurrer was properly given; and from that it is clear he was competent. He states that he had no interest in the matter — was not acting for himself or his mother — but that defendant came to him- and engaged him to make the contract (as above outlined) as his agent and that he did so. The contract
Defendant makes an effort to show that the testimony tending to prove Fred to he deceased’s agent should not he believed. But on demurrer we should not consider that question. '
• The judgment is reversed and cause remanded.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.