Sylvia Pride v. Boone County Sheriff's Department and Diana O'Neill
Opinion
IN THE MISSOURI COURT OF APPEALS
WESTERN DISTRICT SYLVIA PRIDE, )
) Appellant, )
) WD85605
v. )
) OPINION FILED: ) May 2, 2023
BOONE COUNTY SHERIFF’S ) DEPARTMENT and DIANA O’NEILL, )
) Respondents. )
Appeal from the Circuit Court of Boone County, Missouri
The Honorable Joshua C. Devine, Judge
Before Division Four: Gary D. Witt, Chief Judge, Presiding, and
Mark D. Pfeiffer and Thomas N. Chapman, Judges Ms. Sylvia Pride (“Pride”) filed a pro se First Amended Petition against the Boone County Sheriff’s Department and individuals serving in the capacity of records custodians (“Sheriff”) and the Boone County Prosecutor’s Office and individuals serving in the capacity of records custodians (“Prosecutor”), alleging noncompliance with Sunshine Law 1 requests for records from their respective departments. A motion to dismiss was filed on behalf of the Sheriff and the Prosecutor asserting that they were the improper defendants for a Sunshine Law lawsuit. 2 The Circuit Court of Boone County, Missouri (“circuit court”), granted the motion to dismiss. We reverse and remand.
We first address whether the circuit court’s dismissal ruling is properly before us, since the circuit court’s dismissal order gave Pride leave to file an amended petition. “Generally, a dismissal without prejudice is not a final, appealable judgment.” Lee v. Mo. Dep’t of Transp., 618 S.W.3d 258, 262 (Mo. App. W.D. 2021). However, when the court dismisses the petition without prejudice for failure to state a claim 3 and the plaintiff elects to stand on her petition rather than pleading additional facts, the judgment of dismissal constitutes an appealable adjudication on the merits. Id. Because Pride decided to stand on her First Amended Petition rather than amending it, her appeal is properly before this Court. 4 2007). All references to Missouri Revised Statutes are to the REVISED STATUTES OF MISSOURI 2016.
We review a circuit court’s grant of a motion to dismiss de novo. Smith v. Humane Soc’y of United States, 519 S.W.3d 789, 797 (Mo. banc 2017).
Though Pride has filed numerous points on appeal, the gravamen of her argument is that she has stated a cause of action for violation of Missouri’s Sunshine Law against the Sheriff and the Prosecutor. We agree.
The Sunshine Law requires each public governmental body to appoint a custodian of its records and, upon request, make available the custodian’s identity and location. . . . The custodian must act on a records request within three business days after receiving it. Accordingly, Appellant’s claim has three elements. [Her] petition needed to allege (1) [her] request for access to a public record; (2) the custodian of records received the request; and (3) the custodian did not respond within three business days thereafter.
A motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim is solely a test of the petition’s adequacy. The petition’s averments are assumed true and construed liberally and favorably to the plaintiff, with no attempt made to determine if they are credible or persuasive. Instead, the petition is reviewed in an almost academic manner to determine if its allegations meet the elements of a recognized or potential cause of action. To reiterate, a court reviewing a motion to dismiss treats all facts alleged as true.
Pennington v. Dobbs, 235 S.W.3d 77, 79 (Mo. App. S.D. 2007) (citations omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted).
First, “public governmental body” is defined by the Sunshine Law as including “[a]ny department or division . . . of any county.” § 610.010(4)(c). Hence, both the Sheriff, Charlier v. Corum, 774 S.W.2d 518, 520 (Mo. App. W.D. 1989), and the consideration. Breeden v. Hueser, 273 S.W.3d 1, 6 (Mo. App. W.D. 2008); Solomon v. St. Louis Cir. Att’y, 640 S.W.3d 462, 472 (Mo. App. E.D. 2022). Accordingly, the motion to dismiss the appeal is denied.
Prosecutor, Starr v. Jackson Cnty. Prosecuting Att’y, 635 S.W.3d 185, 190 n.5 (Mo. App. W.D. 2021), are “public government bodies” as contemplated by the Sunshine Law. 5
Second, Pride’s First Amended Petition has alleged a violation of Missouri’s Sunshine Law by alleging that these two “public governmental bod[ies] allegedly refuse[d] or fail[ed] to respond to a statutorily compliant request.” Id. at 190. For, Pride has alleged that: (1) a request for access to a public record was made to both the Sheriff and the Prosecutor; (2) such request was received by the custodian of records for both the Sheriff and the Prosecutor; and (3) the custodian of records knowingly refused to produce public records in its possession that would have been responsive to the public records request.
While a fact-finder may eventually conclude that Pride’s allegations are not substantiated by the evidence, we are not at that stage of the proceedings. Today, we are only concerned with the notion that Pride has stated a claim for relief. She has. The circuit court erred in dismissing her First Amended Petition.
Accordingly, we reverse the circuit court’s dismissal ruling and remand to the circuit court for further proceedings consistent with today’s ruling.
______________________________________ Mark D. Pfeiffer, Judge
Gary D. Witt, Chief Judge, and Thomas N. Chapman, Judge, concur.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.