A7 Fitness Inc. v. American Strongman Corporation

District Court, E.D. Missouri

A7 Fitness Inc. v. American Strongman Corporation

Trial Court Opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI EASTERN DIVISION

A7 FITNESS, INC., ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) Case No. 4:21-CV-00153 ) AMERICAN STRONGMAN CORP., ) ) Defendant. )

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

On January 18, 2022, the Court granted the Parties’ joint Motion for Extension of Deadlines in the Case Management Order. Docs. [40], [41]. The Court now provides a new case management order with deadlines modified according to the Parties’ request. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the following schedule shall apply in this case, and will be modified only upon a showing of exceptional circumstances: I. SCHEDULING PLAN 1. This case has been assigned to Track 2 (Standard). 2. All motions for joinder of additional parties or amendment of pleadings shall be filed no later than November 18, 2021. 3. Disclosure shall proceed in the following manner: (a) The parties shall make all disclosures required by Rule 26(a)(1), Fed. R. Civ. P., no later than September 21, 2021. (b) On issues where a party bears the burden of proof, the party shall disclose all expert witnesses and provide expert reports required by Rule 26(a)(2), Fed. R. Civ. P., no later than May 18, 2022, and shall make expert witnesses available for depositions, and have depositions completed, no later than June 1, 2022. (c) Each party shall disclose all rebuttal expert witnesses (if any) and provide rebuttal expert reports (if any) no later than June 8, 2022, and shall make expert witnesses available for depositions, and have depositions completed, no later than June 22, 2022. (d) Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Preliminary Infringement Contentions (Local Patent R. 3-1) and Document Production Accompanying Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Preliminary Infringement Contentions (Local Patent R. 3-2) shall be served by Plaintiff on all parties no later than October 18, 2021, or 21 days after the initial Rule 16 Scheduling Conference. (e) Preliminary Counter-Infringement Contentions (Local Patent R. 3-3) shall be served by Defendant on all parties no later than November 15, 2021, or 28 days after service of the Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Preliminary Infringement Contentions pursuant to Local Patent R. 3-1. (f) Preliminary Invalidity Contentions (Local Patent 3-4) and Document Production Accompanying Preliminary Invalidity Contentions (Local Patent R. 3-5) shall be served by Defendant on all parties no later than December 6, 2021, or 49 days after service of the Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Preliminary Infringement Contentions pursuant to Local patent R. 3-1. (g) The Exchange of Proposed Terms and Claim Elements for Construction (Local Patent R. 4-1) and the Exchange of Preliminary Claim Constructions and Extrinsic Evidence (Local Patent R. 4-2) shall be simultaneously served by the Parties upon one another and the Court no later than February 17, 2022, or 42 days after service of the Preliminary Invalidity Contentions under Local Patent R. 3-4. (h) No later than March 3, 2022, or 14 days after service of the Exchange of Proposed Terms and Claim Elements for Construction (Local Patent R. 4-1) and the Exchange of Preliminary Claim Constructions and Extrinsic Evidence (Local Patent R. 4-2), the Parties shall notify the Court, and one another, if they believe further claim construction briefing and discovery is required under Local Patent R. 4-3, 4-4, and 4-5. (i) If further claim construction briefing and discovery is required under Local Patent R. 4-3, 4-4, and 4-5, the Parties agree to submit a modified Joint Proposed Scheduling Plan to accommodate such rules 16 5 the subsequent timelines and due dates of this Joint Proposed Scheduling Plan to the Court no later than March 10, 2022. (j) The presumptive limits of ten (10) depositions per side as set forth in Rule 30(a)(2)(A), Fed. R. Civ. P., and twenty-five (25) interrogatories per party as set forth in Rule 33(a), Fed. R. Civ. P., shall apply. (k) The parties shall complete all discovery in this case no later than July 6, 2022. (l) Before filing any discovery memorandum or motion, the parties must first attempt to resolve their discovery dispute without court intervention in compliance with Local Rule 37-3.04. IF the parties are unable to reach agreement without court intervention, they file a joint memorandum requesting a telephone conference with the Court. The memorandum must be filed jointly; must specify the parties’ attempts to achieve a resolution; must succinctly describe the issue(s) in dispute; and must not exceed three (3) pages in length. (m) All discovery motions, including motions to compel, must be pursued in a diligent and timely manner. All discovery motions must be filed no later than ten (10) days after either a teleconference conducted pursuant to section (g) or the denial of the parties’ joint request for a teleconference. The Court will not consider motions to compel filed more than fourteen (14) days following the discovery deadline set out above. Pursuant to E.D. Mo. L.R. 37-3.04, no motion to compel will be considered unless the parties have first attempted to resolve the dispute without court intervention. 4. This case shall be referred to alternative dispute resolution on April 1, 2022, and that reference shall terminate on June 1, 2022. 5. Any motions to dismiss, for summary judgment, motions for judgment on the pleadings, or if applicable, any motion to exclude testimony pursuant to Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc.,

509 U.S. 507

(1993) or Kumho Tire Co. Ltd v. Carmichael,

526 U.S. 137

(1999), must be filed no later than July 27, 2022. Any response shall be filed no later than August 29, 2022. Any reply shall be filed no later than September 8, 2022. In the event dispositive motions are filed prior to the above specified date, the opposing party shall file a response thirty (30) days after the filing of the dispositive motion. A reply may be filed ten (10) days after the filing of the response. Briefing of such motions shall be governed by E.D. Mo. L.R. 4.01. 6. For all filings of twenty (20) or more pages or with ten (10) or more pages of attachments, parties must submit courtesy copies to the Court. II. ORDER RELATING TO TRIAL This action is set for a JURY trial on February 1, 2023, at 09:00AM. This is a four-week docket, and the parties are expected to be ready and available for trial on the first day of the docket and thereafter on twenty-four hours notice. Pursuant to Local Rule 8.04, the Court may tax against one or all parties the per diem, mileage, and othe repenses of providing a jury for the parties, when the case is terminated or settled by the parties at a time too late to cancel the jury attendance or to use the summoned jurors in another trial, unless good cause for the delayed termination or settlement is shown. In this case, unless otherwise ordered by the Court, the attorneys shall, not less than twenty (20) days prior to the date set for trial: 1. Stipulation: Meet and jointly prepare and file with the Clerk a JOINT stipulation of all uncontested facts, which may be read into evidence subject to any objections of any party set forth in said stipulation (including a brief summary of the case which may be used on Voir Dire). 2. Witnesses: a. Deliver to opposing counsel, and to the Clerk, a list of all proposed witnesses, identifying those witnesses who will be called to testify and those who may be called. b. Except for good cause shown, no party will be permitted to call any witnesses not listed in compliance with this Order. 3. Exhibits: a. Mark for identification all exhibits to be offered in evidence at the trial (Plaintiffs to use Arabic numerals and Defendants to use letters, e.g., Pltf-1, Def.-A, or Pltf Jones-1, Deft Smith-A, if there is more than one plaintiff or defendant), and deliver to opposing evidence and those that may be introduced. The list shall clearly indicate for each business record whether the proponent seeks to authenticate the business record by affidavit or declaration pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 902(11) or 902(12). b. Submit said exhibits or true copies thereof, and copies of all affidavits or declarations pursuant toFed. R. Evid. 902(11) or 902(12), to opposing counsel for examination. Prior to trial, the parties shall stipulate which exhibits may be introduced without objection or preliminary identification, and shall file written objections to all other exhibits. c. Except for good cause shown, no party will be permitted to offer any exhibits not identified or not submitted by said party for examination by opposing counsel in compliance with this Order. Any objections not made in writing at least ten (10) days prior to trial may be considered waived. 4. Depositions, Interrogatory Answers, and Requests for Admissions: a. Deliver to opposing counsel and to the Clerk a list of all interrogatory answers or parts thereof and depositions or parts thereof (identified by page and line numbers), and answers to requests for admissions proposed to be offered in evidence. At least ten (10) days before trial, opposing counsel shall state in writing any objections to such testimony and shall identify any additional portions of such depositions not listed by the offering party which opposing counsel proposes to offer. b. Except for good cause shown, no party will be permitted to offer any interrogatory answer, or deposition or part thereof, or answer to a request for admission not listed in compliance with this Order. Any objections not made as above required may be considered waived. 5. Instructions: Submit to the Court and to opposing counsel their written request for instructions and forms of verdicts reserving the right to submit requests for additional or modified instructions at least ten (10) days before trial in light of opposing party’s requests for instructions. (Each request must be supported by at least one pertinent citation.). 6. Trial Brief: Submit to the Court and opposing counsel a trial brief stating the legal and factual issues and authorities relied on and discussing any anticipated substantive or procedural problems. 7. Motions In Limine: File all motions in limine to exclude evidence, and submit a courtesy copy directly to the Court’s chambers, at least fourteen (14) days before trial. Responses shall be filed at least seven (7) days prior to trial. Failure to comply with any part of this Order may result in the imposition of sanctions. Dated this 19" day of January, 2022.

SARAH E. PITLYK UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Reference

Status
Unknown